How Giorgia Meloni Outlasted Berlusconi, Clashed with Trump, and Became Kyiv’s Key Ally in Southern Europe
- Giorgia Meloni became the first woman to serve as Italy’s prime minister, breaking Berlusconi’s record thanks to her ability to manage the coalition and adapt to systemic politics.
- Meloni has consistently supported Ukraine, demonstrating a commitment to Euro-Atlanticism that contrasts with her coalition partners’ pro-Kremlin sympathies, and at the same time upholds the principles of traditional Christian identity, criticizing Donald Trump for his deal with Putin.
24 Channel, together with Italian experts Riccardo Alcaro and Lorenzo Castellani, examined the phenomenon of Giorgia Meloni, a far-right politician who has broken Berlusconi’s record, consistently supports Ukraine, dislikes Putin, and isn’t afraid to criticize Trump.
For several weeks now, Ukrainian social media users have been turning an old speech by Italian politician Giorgia Meloni into memes and jokes. Everyone is noting her incredibly charismatic voice, expressive facial expressions, and gestures – users joke that the Italian prime minister sometimes simply doesn’t know what to do with her hands. They also say they listen to her exclusively while standing. Out of respect.
But behind this southern theatricality lies an iron political will. While some on the European right are cozying up to Moscow, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni delivers speeches that draw standing ovations in Kyiv and make the Kremlin grind its teeth.
How did Giorgia Meloni manage to break Berlusconi’s record, why does her support remain strong, and how did she put Donald Trump in his place? Read about it in this report from 24 Channel. To help us understand the nature of the Meloni phenomenon, we spoke with Italian political scientist Lorenzo Castellani, a professor at LUISS University in Rome, and Riccardo Alcaro, a political risk analyst at the Rome Institute of International Relations .
From a waitress in Garbatella to breaking Berlusconi’s record
Giorgia Meloni’s story is a classic “girl from the people” tale of a self-made woman who defied all odds. She was born in Rome in 1977, though she has southern roots. Her father is from Sardinia, and her mother was born in Sicily.
When Giorgia was just one year old, her father left the family and moved to the Canary Islands. Her mother raised her in Garbatella – a poor working-class neighborhood in the Italian capital, where left-wing sentiments have traditionally prevailed.
Before entering the world of big-time politics, the future prime minister worked as a nanny, waitress, and bartender at famous Roman nightclubs.
At age 15, she defied the norms of her neighborhood and joined the youth wing of the post-fascist Italian Social Movement (MSI). Her political rise was meteoric: in 2008, at age 31, Giorgia became the youngest minister in Italian history, heading the Ministry of Youth Affairs in the government of Silvio Berlusconi.
Giorgia Meloni at the start of her political career / file photo
In 2012, Meloni co-founded her own party – Fratelli d’Italia. At the outset, the party had the support of less than 2% of voters, but after ten years of painstaking work, refusing to participate in unpopular “technocratic” governments, and charismatic rhetoric (which is currently making such an impression on Ukrainian social media), she has led the party to first place in the country.
Ukrainian social media is captivated by Giorgia Meloni’s charisma – watch the video:
At its core, “Brothers of Italy” is a mix of hardline national conservatism, right-wing populism, and a post-fascist background. This must be acknowledged and spoken about openly.
Meloni’s party grew out of the remnants of the former neo-fascist Italian Social Movement and has even retained the tricolor flame – associated with the Mussolini era – in its logo. Their ideology is based on the classic slogan “God, Fatherland, Family” and calls for:
- strict restrictions on illegal immigration;
- the protection of traditional Christian values;
- the fight against so-called “gender ideology”;
- criticism of the Brussels bureaucracy in favor of a “Europe of Nations.”
However, unlike many European far-right parties, “Brothers of Italy” has firmly enshrined Euro-Atlanticism and loyalty to NATO in its platform, and Meloni herself has deliberately distanced herself from nostalgia for totalitarianism, likening herself in spirit to British Conservatives or American Republicans.
Meloni’s viral video ahead of her election victory on September 25, 2022, in which the politician plays on her last name – Meloni, meaning “melon”:
It was precisely this ideological cocktail that brought her victory in 2022, when she became Italy’s first female prime minister. But the real miracle happened after the election.
Italy is known for its political instability: since World War II, the country has seen nearly seventy different governments. Even Silvio Berlusconi, who was considered unsinkable, lasted at the helm of a single cabinet for a maximum of 1,412 days (from 2001 to 2005). Meloni has already surpassed that record.
Meloni is the first woman to lead the Italian government / Photo: Getty Images
The Secret to Meloni’s Success
The secret to Giorgia Meloni’s political longevity lies in her ability to rein in her own coalition partners – the perpetually rebelliousMatteo Salvini, and Berlusconi’s heirs – by keeping key decisions in her own hands, and by fitting into the political system at the right time.
As explained by Italian political scientist Lorenzo Castellani, a professor at LUISS University in Rome, Meloni succeeded in doing what usually trips up other populists – transforming street slogans into a stable state apparatus.
Giorgia Meloni’s success is based on a combination of qualities that is relatively rare among the European right: a clear ideological stance, political discipline, and institutional reliability. She has maintained a recognizable conservative-nationalist identity on issues of migration, family, security, and national interests, without turning her government into a constant adversary of Italy’s European and Atlantic partners. This is the key difference. Many right-wing leaders are capable of mobilizing a protest electorate, but far fewer manage to transform that protest into a convincing and viable government project.
According to Castellani, unlike maverick politicians, Meloni was shaped over the years within Italy’s center-right tradition and had behind her a party with strict discipline and a core leadership team. And once she found herself in the prime minister’s chair, she soberly assessed the reality of the situation: Italy, with its enormous public debt, dependence on European markets, and EU funds, simply cannot afford to destabilize the budget or go to war with Brussels.
Therefore, Meloni clearly distinguished between the high-profile rhetoric aimed at voters and the real responsibilities of governing: she maintained a pro-Atlantic course, supported Ukraine, and exercised fiscal prudence, thereby reassuring financial markets.
Her strength also lies in her ability to occupy a complex but potentially very productive position: she positions herself as the leader of the conservative right, yet at the same time remains an acceptable interlocutor for the European establishment. In this sense, her goal is not to be the most radical voice in Europe, but rather the most convincing leader of the radical-conservative camp. Meloni has demonstrated that the European right can become a stable political force if it manages to combine electoral radicalism with pragmatism in governing the state.
Unwavering support for Kyiv and no concessions to Moscow: why Meloni did not follow the path of Le Pen or the AfD
Since her appointment in October 2022, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has consistently and resolutely supported Ukraine in its fight against Russian aggression, despite certain disagreements within her coalition and ongoing domestic political debates.
Giorgia Meloni is a role model for the right in Europe – though not for everyone / Photo: Getty Images
The main mystery for many observers: why has an Italian nationalist become a staunch advocate for Kyiv, while France’s “National Rally” Marine Le Pen and Germany’s “Alternative for Germany” (AfD) Alice Weidel have been promoting Kremlin narratives for years?
As Riccardo Alcaro, a political risk analyst at the Rome Institute of International Relations, explains, the secret lies in political pragmatism and the unique characteristics of Italy itself.
I wouldn’t call Meloni a pro-European politician, but rather a Euro-pragmatist. Her main political trait is her ability to be a chameleon and adapt depending on the circumstances. When, in 2022, she unexpectedly received 26% of the vote instead of the 3–4% her party was accustomed to, she instantly realized that her new electorate was much more moderate. The best way to retain these voters was to immediately establish herself as a reliable international leader. And the only way to do that was to demonstrate unwavering support for Ukraine.
Moreover, unlike other European far-right figures, Meloni did not have “Putin’s baggage.” In Italy itself, the “Kremlin-friendly” niche was already firmly occupied by her coalition partners – Silvio Berlusconi and Matteo Salvini – who had admired the Russian dictator for years.
After Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, this closeness to Moscow began to take a toxic toll on their approval ratings. Meloni, however, never harbored any affection for Putin – and skillfully capitalized on this contrast. She did not abandon her predecessor’s Mario Draghi ’s policy of supporting Kyiv; on the contrary, she cemented it. This immediately opened the door to Washington for her during the Biden administration and allayed Brussels’ main fear: that Italy would become the EU’s second weak spot after Orbán’s Hungary.
The Russians constantly attack Meloni for her support of Ukraine / photo – Getty Images
Moscow did not forgive this stance. Russian propaganda regularly smears Meloni, and in April 2026, it escalated into an open diplomatic scandal.
Propagandist Vladimir Solovyov, who still cannot get over the seizure of his villas on Lake Como in Italy, switched to Italian on live TV and hurled insults at the prime minister – calling her a “fascist,” a “bad woman,” and a “certified idiot.” Most interestingly, the propagandist accused Meloni of “betraying” not only her right-wing views, but also Donald Trump himself.
A viral clip featuring Meloni during the G7 summit in Canada – watch the video:
In Rome, they didn’t beat around the bush. The Italian Foreign Ministry immediately summoned Russian Ambassador Alexei Paramonov, and Meloni herself responded to Solovyov on social media that same evening – briefly and without diplomatic niceties.
By his very nature, a zealous propagandist for the regime can teach neither unity nor freedom. But these caricatures certainly won’t make us change course. Unlike others, we have no strings attached, no masters, and we do not follow any orders. Our compass remains the same: Italy’s interests. And we will continue to follow it with pride, much to the chagrin of propagandists everywhere,” Meloni’s response to the Russian media attack.
Why Meloni Didn’t Become Trump’s Favorite
For a long time, Meloni was considered the ideal “bridge” between Europe and Donald Trump. It seemed that with the Republican’s return to the White House, the conservative Italian prime minister w she will become his main "favorite" in the Old World, given their similar ideological views. However, things did not turn out as expected.
The “bromance” with Trump didn’t work out / Photo – Getty Images
This is because representatives of right-wing parties around the world view various issues differently and have their own approaches and positions. While the neo-isolationists of Trump’s MAGA movement view geopolitics as a business deal and are willing to negotiate with dictators for short-term gain, and authoritarian pragmatists like Orbán in the past, and now Fico, use right-wing slogans to blackmail Brussels and secure cheap Russian energy resources, Meloni belongs to a completely different camp – that of Atlantic conservatives, for whom values are not just empty words.
As Riccardo Alcaro explains, while Meloni had an ideological chasm with Joe Biden despite complete alignment on foreign policy, with Trump it was the opposite: ideologically they are close, but their foreign policy interests have diverged sharply.
Inthe first year after Trump’s return, Meloni adopted a strategy of appeasement: when he imposed tariffs on the EU, she sought a compromise; when the scandal with Zelenskyy in the Oval Office broke out, Trump met with Putin in Alaska, andtheRussian-American“28-point plan”emerged without Ukraine’s participation, Meloni worked with EU leaders to limit the damage and stay true to the pro-Ukrainian line.
But in 2026, a turning point occurred. First, the U.S. launched a war against Iran, which led to a spike in gas prices and sparked widespread discontent among Italians. Then Trump publicly “ launched a furious attack on Pope Leo XIV ” because of her anti-war stance.
For Meloni, who builds her political image on defending traditional Christian identity, remaining silent in such a situation was impossible – she cautiously criticized Washington.
“I express my solidarity with Pope Leo.” Frankly speaking, I would feel uncomfortable in a society where religious leaders do what political leaders tell them to do,” Meloni stated in the spring of 2026, at the height of the scandal surrounding Trump’s attack on the Pope.
Trump took this as a “vassal’s” rebellion and erupted in even greater fury. The climax came at the G7 summit in France, where the American president tried to publicly humiliate the Italian prime minister, claiming that she “She begged him to take a photo with her.” By that point, closeness to Trump had already become toxic in the eyes of Italian voters, so Meloni struck back, effectively playing on national pride: “I don’t beg, and neither does Italy.”
Meloni isn’t afraid to show her strength / Photo – Office of the President of Ukraine
Of course, Rome did not burn its bridges with the U.S. – too much of its defense depends on Washington. But the illusions have been dispelled: Meloni made it clear that she has no intention of playing along with the White House in defiance of her own principles and European security.
This was most clearly evident in October 2026, when Trump reached an agreement with Putin on supplying Russian diesel to the global market temporarily eased sanctions. Meloni spoke out strongly against it, calling the agreement a “very risky decision” that legitimizes Moscow and gives the Kremlin money for the war. And speaking before Italian parliamentarians, she outright denounced attempts to pressure Kyiv into making concessions.
I do not miss the Russian tanks that crushed the uprisings in Prague and Budapest, nor do I miss the Berlin Wall. And no one will convince me that the surrender of those defending their freedom can be called peace. “The peace we seek and are working to build – even at the cost of losing consensus – is a just peace,” Meloni declared. And this, by the way, is a hint and Action Plan for Marine Le Pen, the Frontrunner in the 2027 French Elections.
In Trump’s circle, European politicians are not divided into “right” and “left,” but rather into those who are willing to play by the White House’s rules unconditionally, and everyone else. As Italian political scientist Lorenzo Castellani explains, Washington is accustomed to judging partners not by traditional European standards, but by personal loyalty, ideological affinity, and a willingness to break the old world order.
Italy’s Choice in the Meloni Era: To Be Strong / Photo: Office of the President of Ukraine
According to the expert, for years the White House has relied on politicians who openly clash with Brussels – such as former Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, who ultimately lost the election in the spring of 2026.
Trump’s inner circle generally favors leaders who directly and confrontationally invoke national sovereignty, as well as political forces in other countries that lean toward the anti-establishment and sovereignist right. They are perceived not merely as conservatives, but as participants in a broader political uprising against globalization, supranational governance, progressive cultural norms, and the liberal international order. In addition, Trump expects these leaders to recognize the priority of American national interests.
But this formula failed with Meloni. During the election campaign, she spoke about migrants, borders, and the traditional family almost in the language of Trump supporters. However, once she took the prime minister’s seat, she drastically changed the rules of the game: she remained loyal to NATO, firmly supported Ukraine, and refrained from turning Italy into the European Union’s chief troublemaker.
As the political scientist notes, Meloni “is not an organic part of Trump’s political world,” because in government she is guided not by street slogans but by cold calculation.
She can rather be described as a statesmanlike conservative: a leader who uses nationalist rhetoric but recognizes the constraints imposed by alliances, public finances, diplomacy, and institutions.
It is precisely in this balancing act that the secret of her current global influence lies. Unlike anti-establishment populists, whose political careers sooner or later crash against reality, Giorgia Meloni has managed to win over both conservatives on both sides of the Atlantic and the European establishment.
For Trump’s inner circle, she may be an ally on many cultural and political issues. But at the same time, she is the head of a European government whose interests do not always align with those of the Trump administration. Her value lies precisely in this dual position: she is able to maintain communication with the Trump camp without becoming subservient to it.
Часті питання
Why has George Meloni become popular on Ukrainian social media?
George Meloni has become popular on Ukrainian social media thanks to her incredibly charismatic voice, expressive facial expressions, and gestures. Her speeches are met with admiration – users joke that they listen to her while standing out of respect.
How did George Meloni become Italy's first female prime minister?
Giorgia Meloni became Italy’s first female prime minister thanks to a combination of conservative-nationalist identity, political discipline, and institutional reliability. She maintained a clear stance on migration and security without turning her government into an adversary of Italy’s European partners.
Why does George Meloni support Ukraine, unlike other European far-right figures?
Giorgia Meloni supports Ukraine out of political pragmatism and due to Italy’s specific circumstances. She did not have “Putin’s baggage,” while her coalition partners had already carved out a niche as friends of the Kremlin. Meloni realized that her new electorate is more moderate, and the best way to retain these voters is to become a reliable international leader by supporting Ukraine.