The idea of exchanging the Donbas for Ukraine’s NATO membership could turn out to be yet another negotiating trap set by Russia, which seeks to gain control of Ukrainian territories without offering Kyiv any real security guarantees. The Kremlin continues to insist on maximalist demands, while Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are pushing vague language about “practical compromises.” At the same time, such proposals may conceal an attempt to force Ukraine to agree to territorial concessions in exchange for promises that no one will ultimately guarantee.
Scott Lucas, a professor of international politics at the Clinton Institute at University College Dublin, explained in an interview with 24 Channel why the proposal “Donbas in exchange for NATO” could be part of Russian negotiating tactics and how the Kremlin is using Witkoff and Kushner to serve its own interests. The professor also assessed the prospects for a peace agreement, explained why Ukraine should insist on a ceasefire before discussing territorial issues, and discussed what the reduction in NATO summits means for the Alliance’s future. In addition, Lucas analyzed J.D. Vance’s political ambitions and explained what might prevent him from becoming the next U.S. president.
popular videos
What’s Behind the “Donbas in Exchange for NATO” Idea
Let’s begin our discussion with the negotiations to end the war in Ukraine and the new ideas reportedly proposed by Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner. Volodymyr Zelenskyy recently stated that the U.S. side is allegedly considering Donbas in exchange for Ukraine’s NATO membership. At the same time, according to The New York Times, Russia continues to make maximalist demands. How do you assess this proposal – the Donbas in exchange for NATO membership? How realistic is it, and could it serve as a basis for negotiations?
My assessment of this alleged Russian proposal – to cede the remainder of the Donetsk region, as well as the Luhansk region in the east of the country, after which Ukraine could join NATO – is this: this must be approached with great, great caution. I need to explain this in a broader context.
Let’s remember that early last week, on Tuesday and Wednesday, during the talks in Abu Dhabi, the Russians had a document outlining their position. We know about it because someone leaked a copy to the media. The document spoke of the need to discuss a pan-European security architecture, not Ukraine’s security – specifically, a pan-European security architecture.
By this, the Russians meant that NATO should effectively return to its 1997 status. This means that there should be no NATO bases or military personnel in the Baltic states or Poland, which joined NATO after 1997.
Professor of International Politics Warns of Threats to Ukraine: Video
Now, if Russia has no intention of allowing NATO personnel and bases in the Baltics and Poland, why is it suddenly saying that Ukraine can join NATO? Moreover, when Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner arrived in Moscow after their meeting in Abu Dhabi, which seems to have been on Wednesday or Thursday of last week, Vladimir Putin publicly stated – or Russian state media made it clear – that there cannot be any Western military personnel in Ukraine.
If Western military personnel are present in Ukraine, Russia could attack them as part of the ongoing war. So if Putin says there can be no Western military personnel in Ukraine, how can Russia at the same time say, “Oh, but you can be a member of NATO”? Something doesn’t add up here.
This can be explained by only one scenario. Witkoff and Kushner returned from Moscow, and that same evening, on Thursday, met with Volodymyr Zelenskyy at a military airfield near Dublin. I remember it was Thursday because I spoke with you that evening.
And it was probably there that this proposal was made. However, it does not align with Russia’s other statements. If we look at it another way, it appears that they are trying to force Ukraine to agree to cede territory in exchange for a promise of NATO membership, and only then discuss the terms of membership. In other words, Russia gets what it wants – territory – and Ukraine might get something in return.
That’s a classic negotiating tactic, isn’t it? It’s almost like “name your price.” If you can get Zelenskyy to finally agree that the Donbas could be ceded under certain circumstances, what price could you then offer? The Russians will try to set it as low as possible.
I think Ukraine already understands this scheme. If we go back to the basic principles, even before we start talking about Donbas in exchange for NATO or a pan-European security architecture, Ukraine and Europe emphasize: first, we need to agree on a ceasefire along the current front lines.
We must discuss territorial integrity. In other words, Russia must not be given the opportunity to lay claim to new territories. We must also discuss security guarantees for Ukraine. And only after that should we move on to the issue of a pan-European security architecture.
This is exactly how it should happen. Otherwise, you allow the Russians to control the negotiating agenda and resort to manipulation to force Ukraine to cede even more territory at a relatively low cost.
A Possible Scenario of Negotiation Manipulation
I personally have not seen any convincing reports that Russia is ready to agree to Ukraine’s NATO membership. Do you think the Americans have Russia’s consent for Ukraine’s accession to the Alliance, or is this just an assumption by Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, who are trying to achieve something?
As I said, we don’t know for sure. We don’t know what went on behind closed doors in Moscow, but I can imagine one possible scenario.
Here’s the scenario I’m considering. Putin or his intermediary – his manipulator, Kirill Dmitriev – tells Kushner and Witkoff: “Listen, go back and tell Zelenskyy that if he gives up Donbas, Ukraine might be able to join NATO.”
And Witkoff and Kushner think about what they themselves want. Of course, they want the fighting to stop, because they need all those economic deals with the Russians. That’s exactly what they’re pushing for. So they go back, excited by this prospect, and think they’ll tell Zelenskyy just that.
Now let’s imagine that Zelenskyy replies to Witkoff and Kushner: “You know what, that’s not a bad proposal. We’re ready to go along with it; we’ll give up the rest of the Donetsk region.” Of course, Zelenskyy cannot make such a decision without consulting with parliament and the Ukrainian people, but let’s assume he agrees to consider this proposal. And then he asks: “You did promise that we’d join NATO, right?”
Now imagine that Witkoff and Kushner return to the Russians and report that Zelenskyy has agreed to hand over the Donbas. In response, the Russians say: “All right, let’s discuss the terms of Ukraine’s accession to NATO. In fact, Ukraine can join the Alliance if it reverts to 1997 borders.” This is exactly what Russia has been demanding: NATO must revert to its 1997 borders, which do not include Ukraine. So, Kyiv ends up with an empty promise.
Do Witkoff and Kushner understand this? They aren’t diplomats. They have no experience dealing with the Russians. The Russians are constantly manipulating them, while the Americans themselves are eager to strike economic deals with Moscow. So Russia is once again manipulating them, forcing them to offer Ukraine a deal that is actually just another way to advance its maximalist demands. That’s exactly how I see this story unfolding right now.
Personally, I cannot imagine a scenario in which the Russians, during a meeting with the Americans, would simply say, “You know, Ukraine can join NATO at any cost.” From your perspective, is Russia trying to force Zelenskyy to give up the Donbas, while at the same time giving Ukrainians the impression that they’ll be able to join NATO? And after the war ends, could some Alliance member states still block Ukraine’s accession for another five years?
Yes, exactly. What is Russia doing? It’s saying: give us something now, and maybe you’ll get something later. That’s exactly what it’s doing.
And again, there’s a former Ukrainian lawmaker who voiced this scenario. I’ll probably mention her name in a moment. But there’s another possibility, Daniele, and again, we don’t know for sure what happened in Moscow.
Perhaps Witkoff and Kushner are thinking: if we tell this to Zelenskyy and force him to agree, then we’ll return to Moscow and inform the Russians that Zelenskyy is ready to cede the Donbas on the condition that Ukraine has the prospect of joining NATO. In other words, the Russians didn’t say this outright, but Witkoff and Kushner decided on their own to try to secure such an agreement from Zelenskyy.
Of course, if that’s exactly how it happened, what do you think the Kremlin will tell Witkoff and Kushner? It will say, “No, we won’t allow Ukraine to join NATO.” In other words, it’s a dead end. Such a proposal has no prospects whatsoever. Ukraine has no reason to consider it, and rightly so. After all, when you start discussing giving up the entire Donbas, you’re playing by Russia’s rules, following Russia’s agenda.
You must act in accordance with your own agenda: first, a ceasefire; then, discussions on security guarantees for Russia – provided that Ukraine also receives security guarantees and is not forced to cede additional territories. That is exactly how the process should unfold. Will Witkoff and Kushner act exactly this way? Probably not, since Steve Witkoff still believes that the entire Donbas should be handed over to Russia.
Jared Kushner’s Statement and the Issue of “Practical Compromises”
And it’s truly interesting to analyze this with you, especially in light of Jared Kushner’s most recent statement. Over the weekend, he commented on the media coverage of the negotiations. I quote: “The press has reported on the maximalist positions proposed by both sides, along with harsh political rhetoric. In our private discussions, both sides understand that practical compromises will be needed to end this war.” What could this mean?
This is typical Kushner rhetoric: something along the lines of, “Yes, both sides will make concessions,” and so on. It’s very, very vague. In particular, the phrase “practical compromises.”
First, I want to clarify: the scenario we just discussed was actually outlined by former Ukrainian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Drychko. Now let’s return to Kushner’s remarks about practical compromises. Jared, what do these practical compromises mean? That is the key question.
It’s worth recalling what proposals Jared Kushner brought to the meeting in Moscow when he spoke about the key elements of a settlement. There are two important points here. First: one of the key elements Kushner mentioned was “safety guarantees.” Fair enough.
But such guarantees only make sense if they ensure Ukraine’s security. At the same time, the Russian concept of security guarantees, which Moscow articulated in late 2021, immediately before the invasion of Ukraine, concerned security guarantees for Europe. It was not about Kyiv’s security, but about the security of Europe and Russia.
When Kushner speaks of vague compromises, does that mean he is referring primarily to security guarantees for Ukraine? Second, Kushner made contradictory statements even before the meetings in Abu Dhabi and Moscow. At first, he said that any settlement must provide for respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity.
He then changed the wording to “sovereignty and authority,” which is not the same as “territorial integrity.” At that point, it began to seem as though he was allowing for the possibility of Ukraine ceding territory. However, during the talks in Abu Dhabi, he returned to the wording regarding territorial integrity. So what is his actual position?
President Zelenskyy raised this issue very clearly at the start of the Abu Dhabi talks. He said that the U.S. and Russia are talking about security guarantees, but their wording remains vague. What exactly do these guarantees mean? Jared Kushner can talk about “practical compromises,” “reasonable compromises,” or any other compromises as much as he likes, but until he explains what they actually entail, it’s just empty rhetoric.
And I come back to the main point: who sets the negotiating agenda? We know what the Kremlin is after. It’s not a compromise, but pushing Russian demands as far as possible. How do I know this? Chief Russian negotiator Vladimir Medinsky told Russian state media that not a single Russian soldier will withdraw from Ukraine.
Moscow is not ready to compromise on the occupied territories. How do I know this? During the talks in Abu Dhabi, Sergey Lavrov stated that Russia is not changing its position. And what is Ukraine’s position? I know: a ceasefire and no territorial concessions. What do the Americans mean when they talk about a compromise between these two fundamentally different positions? I have no idea.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated during a closed-door meeting with Ukrainian journalists this past weekend that only Ukrainians should decide whether they are ready to give up the Donbas in exchange for NATO membership. Could this be yet another hint at a possible plan to end the war, which would involve holding a national referendum on this issue simultaneously with the presidential and parliamentary elections?
I think Zelenskyy made a principled statement here. He essentially said: regardless of what proposal emerges – even if it’s the “Donbas in exchange for NATO” option – he cannot make such a decision on his own. Such issues cannot be decided unilaterally under the Ukrainian Constitution and the country’s system of government. He will have to turn to parliament – and likely to the people as well – to hold a referendum so that Ukrainians can ratify any agreement reached.
I don’t think this means that Zelenskyy is actually seriously considering the “Donbas in exchange for NATO” option. He’s simply reminding journalists: it’s not just my opinion that matters. We must take into account what the Ukrainian people want for their future.
NATO, Fewer Summits, and the Alliance Losing Momentum
Let’s also talk about NATO and its next summit, which is likely to take place in 2028. The Alliance will cancel the 2027 leaders’ summit in Albania and reduce the number of high-level meetings. This comes amid tensions over defense spending, Iran, and Ukraine. In addition, defense ministers will skip the October 2027 meeting, and foreign ministers will meet only once next year instead of twice. What does this mean?
It means that NATO’s leading member in terms of military spending and capabilities – the United States – has effectively stepped aside. Here’s what it means. What’s the point of a NATO leaders’ summit if Donald Trump is sitting at the table? None. Because Trump is chaotic, doesn’t follow a clear agenda, and is driven solely by his own ego.
What’s the point of a summit attended by Vice President J.D. Vance, who doesn’t really believe in the need for European security? What good does such a summit do? Perhaps Secretary of State Marco Rubio won’t be there next year either, since he may run for president. In my opinion, this reflects a growing realization – not only in Europe but also in Canada, which is also a NATO member – that such agreements should be reached not at Alliance summits, but within other multilateral negotiation frameworks.
It’s not ideal. In fact, it’s terrible. But when you have a Trump administration that doesn’t believe in the alliance, expecting NATO to function normally – at least at the summit level – is absurd. At the same time, the Alliance’s day-to-day operations must be ensured. This involves interacting with U.S. officials and resolving practical issues: agreements on troop deployments, the supply of equipment and weapons, as well as coordination in the areas of cybersecurity and maritime security, which we’ve been discussing in recent days.
J.D. Vance’s Presidential Ambitions and U.S. Domestic Politics
Let’s also talk about another interesting development in U.S. domestic politics. J.D. Vance is postponing his decision on whether to run for president due to fears of criticism from Trump and the Republicans’ poor performance in the midterm elections. Could J.D. Vance decide not to run for president at all?
I think Vance is currently assessing his position based on several factors. You’ve already mentioned the first one: Donald Trump publicly humiliated him.
It’s not just a matter of whether Trump would support Vance. J.D. Vance tried to make his move immediately after the midterm elections. His office, as I understand it, issued a statement to the media saying that Vance is leading negotiations to end the war in Iran. From the very beginning – as early as late February – Vance opposed the war with Iran. He signaled this even before the midterm elections, addressing the Iranian people. Vance sent them a letter calling on them: “Let’s resume negotiations.”
In other words, his message was: “I can pull the U.S. out of the war in Iran. This is a good platform from which I can run for president.” However, just a few hours after the Wall Street Journal published a report stating that Vance’s office had highlighted his leading role in negotiations with Iran, Donald Trump wrote on Truth Social that J.D. Vance should focus on exposing Democratic fraud and waste. This is an absurd statement. After all, Donald Trump himself is the problem when it comes to fraud and waste.
But then Trump made even more absurd statements: “We have all of Iran’s money; we control the Strait of Hormuz – why do we need to talk to them?” In fact, this was a signal to Vance: you are not in charge of the negotiations regarding the war in Iran. So Vance’s tactics were exposed by Trump or someone in his inner circle – perhaps the new chief of staff, Stephen Miller.
Now Vance’s position has become less clear, and the Republican Party is in utter disarray following the midterm elections. So which Republicans will he be able to enlist for support if he decides to run for president? Moreover, Marco Rubio, the current Secretary of State, may also try to enter the presidential race.
That’s why it’s worth keeping an eye on his moves, since Rubio has an advantage that Vance doesn’t: he can leave the administration to launch a presidential campaign and thus distance himself from Trump. Vance cannot leave his post – he cannot resign as vice president to launch a presidential campaign.
So, I think Vance is weighing his options right now. And I don’t think that means he won’t run for president. Rather, it’s a way of letting the media know that he’s not going to rush into making public statements just yet. It’s important to remember that presidential campaigns are usually officially announced no earlier than 18 months before the election. That would be around May–June 2027.
So right now, we’re talking more about unofficial signals. If you look closely at U.S. domestic politics, the key question is what Vance’s people are telling Republican donors. A presidential campaign requires enormous funds. Are they telling donors privately that J.D. is hesitating, or are they actually assuring them: “No, he’s still running. We just need to choose the timing of the announcement very carefully”?
If you find an error on this page, select it and press Ctrl + Enter

