Views: Reading time: 21 min

"The Russians Are Lying": An Exclusive Interview with Scott Lucas on the Kremlin's New Traps and the Danger to Ukraine

An Interview with Scott Lucas

Negotiations to end the war are once again entering dangerous territory: while Ukraine insists on a ceasefire and security guarantees, Russia is trying to shift the focus and impose its own vision of Europe’s future. And the visits by U.S. envoys to Moscow and their contradictory statements only raise more questions about the true intentions of U.S. President Donald Trump’s team.

 
Adv

In an exclusive interview with 24 Channel, Professor of International Politics Scott Lucas discussed whether Washington is truly seeking to stop Russian aggression, whether pressure is gradually shifting to Kyiv, and why the Starshield restrictions could become a much more serious problem for Ukraine than it seems at first glance. He also revealed the Kremlin’s latest manipulations and the Russian dictator’s plans regarding NATO.

popular videos

Advertisement

Let’s begin our discussion by highlighting the results of the trilateral talks in Abu Dhabi. Let’s summarize where we stand now after two days of talks between the U.S., Russia, and Ukraine, between Ukraine and its European allies, as well as following Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner’s visit to Moscow and the upcoming meeting in Dublin between U.S. negotiators and President Zelenskyy, as well as the talks between Ukraine and its European allies?

A meeting between two American envoys took place – real estate developer Steve Witkoff and Donald Trump’s son-in-law Jared Kushner – with Vladimir Putin following two days of talks between Ukraine and Russia, with the participation of Americans and European observers.

Advertisement

I think the easiest way to understand this is as follows: there are two different approaches to where we currently stand in the discussions regarding the Russian invasion – one favored by Ukraine and Europe, and the other sought by the Russians.

Ukraine and Europe want – and have been seeking for many months – a ceasefire along the current front line. They want the current front line to mean no territorial changes whatsoever. In other words, they want to prevent any expansion of the Russian occupation, particularly the seizure of the rest of the Donetsk region in eastern Ukraine.

And they want security guarantees for Ukraine that would, of course, protect it from further Russian attacks.

But the Russians want none of this. Instead, they want to push this issue to the background by talking about a pan-European security architecture. It’s quite vague what that means.

Advertisement

I think the Russians are using this mainly to say, “We don’t want to discuss a ceasefire. We don’t want to discuss the current territorial status quo.”

Full interview: watch the video

This brings us back to what the Russians were saying in 2021 before the invasion of Ukraine, namely: “You must provide us with security guarantees.” By this, they meant that NATO should withdraw from the continent.

They were supposed to withdraw, for example, from the Baltic states, and perhaps from Poland as well. This meant withdrawing troops, closing bases, and returning to what the Russians called the 1997 borders.

Of course, NATO rejected this, since a number of states that wanted to join the Alliance after 1997 – including the Baltic states – had asked NATO to ensure their security.

Advertisement

So, Russia has returned to the idea that it wants to work with Europe on security guarantees – but not security guarantees for Ukraine. That takes a back seat.

So what takes priority? This is precisely what was discussed in Abu Dhabi, since we now know from many officials – and, in fact, from the Russians themselves – that they refuse to discuss the implementation of the ceasefire. They refuse to discuss territorial agreements and security guarantees specifically for Ukraine.

Moreover, we know from their chief negotiator, Vladimir Medinsky, that Russia has returned with the most demanding demands. When Medinsky spoke not to Western media but to Russian media, he stated that not a single Russian soldier would retreat.

He said that we would not exchange territories. He also noted that their “security zone” applies not only to Donetsk but also to the small amount of territory that Russia occupies in the Sumy and Kharkiv regions.

Advertisement

Here’s the thing: we were expecting opening statements, and indeed, Kushner and Witkoff’s opening remarks with Putin in front of the cameras boiled down to Kushner discussing the idea of involving Europe in any future negotiations.

Witkoff said that the Russian dictator is wonderful because Putin stated: “Perhaps we will be able to establish a local ceasefire in Kostiantynivka.” This is a city in the Donetsk region that the Russians have been trying to capture for months.

Note this! Zelenskyy explained that Ukrainian troops and Russian occupiers are present in Kostiantynivka, and fighting is ongoing between them. This is The Kremlin's proposal reveals the enemy's plan: Putin wants the Ukrainian Defense Forces to leave the city so he can occupy it.

Advertisement

Putin then responded and essentially said that Europe is not a central player in these negotiations. He showed no signs of being ready to address key issues: a ceasefire and territorial agreements.

One of the key points this week is that Europe must participate in these discussions regarding Ukraine. We cannot try to isolate Ukraine by cutting Europeans out of the process – which is exactly what the Russians want.

Putin stated that he would like to see lasting peace in Ukraine. He also said that foreign troops in Ukraine would be considered legitimate targets for the Russian army. Why, in your opinion, did Trump’s representative travel to Moscow only to hear the same old story again? And here’s another very interesting topic – the humanitarian operation in Kostiantynivka. He claims that Russian forces control Kostiantynivka and can guarantee safety there. He also demands five days to clear mines near the city. What would this give the Russians? Do you see any possibility for this mission at all? And what are your thoughts on the Russian dictator’s latest statements?

Advertisement

Let’s look at each of these points one by one. As for Vladimir Putin’s desire to achieve lasting peace, I think we can set that aside.

After all, can a person seek lasting peace while carrying out mass killings and bombing civilians day and night? I really don’t believe that. Do you want lasting peace, Putin? Accept a ceasefire and the current front lines. But I don’t think we’ve heard him accept that.

Second, I think this is a fairly significant statement. He said not only that he would not accept foreign troops in Ukraine, but also that if foreign troops were there, they would become targets for Russian attacks as the war continues.

Right now, any security guarantee for Ukraine involves Ukraine’s cooperation with foreign militaries; foreign military personnel are part of the security you provide. At the very least, this requires foreign advisers, even if you’re not talking about ground troops.

So, Putin has effectively said, “I’m not going to entertain discussions about security guarantees for Ukraine.” This needs to be acknowledged, and I hope Witkoff acknowledges it.

Third, regarding what happened in Kostiantynivka, as far as I know, that is not territory under Russian control.

So what is Putin trying to achieve? He’s trying to imply that everyone acknowledges the Russians control it, since he’s supposedly the one calling for a ceasefire. Why is this important?

First, Russia has been unable to establish control over this territory for months. This has laid bare the fact that the Russians aren’t advancing as quickly as expected in the Donetsk region, and this has become a source of embarrassment for them.

What Ukraine did earlier this week was quite smart. When the Russians said, “Okay, let’s talk about us getting more territory in Donetsk Oblast,” Ukraine stepped in and said, “You’ve been lying about how much territory you control, haven’t you?”

Your military commanders are lying about your control over territory in the Donetsk region, and this really upset the Russians because they were exposed. And so Putin came back to say, “Look at us – we’re in control here, at least in Kostiantynivka.”

And then, of course, if there’s a ceasefire and it’s supposedly broken or violated, it’s Ukraine that’s violating it. That’s a ploy, and I hope Witkoff understands that.

So, your general, broad question: why did they go there? Let’s take them at their word – they went there to try to stop the invasion.

And I have nothing against Witkoff traveling to Russia to stop the invasion. But on what terms are you going to stop it? The terms must be a ceasefire based on the current front lines, with no further surrender of territory.

Let me tell you a short story that exposes both how untrustworthy Kushner and Witkoff are and how the Russians are taking advantage of this. Ahead of the meetings in Abu Dhabi this week, Jared Kushner outlined the purpose of the meeting.

He identified five things the Americans wanted from it. At their core, they revolved around the idea of mutual security guarantees.

And then he said that this should include respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity. That would mean the Russians have to withdraw from Ukraine, right? That is Ukraine’s sovereign territory.

So, right before the meetings in Abu Dhabi, Kushner changed that and said, “Oh, this means respect for sovereignty and for governance – the ability of people to govern themselves.” He dropped the phrase “territorial integrity.” Then, once he was at the meetings in Abu Dhabi, he brought back the phrase “territorial integrity.” So which one is correct?

Are you really proposing a settlement based on territorial integrity, which means that the Russians will eventually have to leave Ukraine? Or are you saying that it’s based on governance, in which case you’re allowing the Russians to stay there as long as they want?

I don’t usually like to make predictions, but right now I’ll predict that Witkoff and Kushner will talk about a pan-European security architecture. They won’t talk about a ceasefire.

Let’s then touch on this agreement regarding the post-war European security architecture, which is being discussed between the Americans and the Russians without European participation. According to Axios, the Russians claimed that Putin launched the invasion of Ukraine because President Biden did not respond to his 2021 letter, which outlined Russia’s security concerns. Is this yet another attempt by the Russian side to create a new architecture without taking European security interests into account – with NATO withdrawing from Poland, Latvia, Estonia, and Lithuania, and changes to the military posture in Eastern Europe?

You know the answer to that question yourself when you ask me. The Russians are lying.

In 2021, when they rolled out all this rhetoric about how you must provide us with security guarantees, the Biden administration, of course, responded to it. European countries did the same.

It would have been irresponsible not to respond to the Russians. But they told the Russians, “No, we’ll talk to you about security guarantees, but we won’t discuss a return to the 1997 lines.”

Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania will not allow NATO to withdraw to the 1997 lines, because that would mean they would be left completely defenseless against the Russians.

We cannot retreat to the 1997 lines, because that would mean losing the current situation in Poland, which is a very important part of European defense. In fact, the Poles are among the largest contributors to defense, spending about 4.8% of GDP on security.

So they have responded to Putin, but the Russians are doing this for several reasons. One of them is an attempt to turn this into an issue concerning Europe as a whole, rather than an invasion of Ukraine.

Indeed, bearing in mind that the invasion of Ukraine has been ongoing since 2014, when they seized Crimea and attempted to tear away the east, they are doing this because it makes them appear to be victims.

Third, they’re blaming Biden because they know Trump doesn’t like Biden. So they think it sounds good to Trump if they blame him. It’s a pretty transparent tactic.

The question is, how do you respond to this? And you respond like this: “All right, don’t lie. We’ve discussed security guarantees with you, and we’ll continue to discuss them if you realize that this includes not only the U.S. but also European countries, and it includes Ukraine – and it starts with Ukraine’s security.”

Throughout these negotiations in Abu Dhabi, the U.S. side is once again imposing restrictions on Starshield. As Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated, slowdowns in Starshield’s operations have been observed again for several days now. So what is your reaction? In other words, is this a clear signal that the U.S. side is trying to push not the Kremlin, but Ukraine, toward capitulation?

This is a very important episode that’s worth Keep an eye on Starshield. Now we know the background to this.

Last month, when Donald Trump and his entourage were heading to the Kremlin, someone – and I suspect it was likely Starshield owner Elon Musk, and the White House shut down or limited Starshield’s operations to 100 miles per hour for over a week.

When you limit Starshield to 160 kilometers per hour, two things happen. First, it affects Ukraine’s air defense, and second, it affects operations on the front lines.

A week later, following a phone call between Volodymyr Zelenskyy and U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, the service was restored, but now it’s being restricted again.

But pay very close attention to Zelenskyy’s statement, because now he’s citing a fact: does this mean we can’t use Starshield in Russian-occupied territories?

Remember, Ukraine cannot use Starshield inside Russia. You cannot use it for operations or counteroffensives against the Russians.

Zelenskyy’s statement suggests that he believes the restrictions may have been imposed now because the Americans are about to tell Ukraine that Starshield cannot be used to attack Russians in Russian-occupied territory within Ukraine.

In other words, Ukraine cannot attack Russian occupation forces. This leads to two things:

  • First, it means that Ukraine cannot fight to liberate its own territory.
  • Second, it means that if the Russians attack you from occupied territory – as they are doing – you cannot strike back.

You cannot defend yourself against these occupying forces. This is what Zelenskyy suspects is happening. At least publicly, that is exactly what he is saying.

My question is: Do Ukrainian officials know privately that this is precisely why Starshield has been restricted again? That Trump’s people are saying you can no longer use Starshield near the front lines in Russian-occupied territory.

What lies ahead for Pete Hagseth, who has so far avoided impeachment

Let’s also touch on another interesting topic: domestic politics in the United States and the fate of Pete Hagseth, the so-called “Secretary of War,” and his possible impeachment in the U.S. Congress. What is his fate now? Does he have a bright future?

Pete Hagseth has always believed he has a bright future. The problem is that no one else has a bright future because of what he’s doing.

So, The defense minister "survived" the vote, which could have led to his impeachment in the House of Representatives on Wednesday evening.

I think we should say that this was just the first act of a play that will go on longer if he doesn’t leave the Trump administration.

Once Democrats take control of the House of Representatives and the Senate – which won’t happen until January 3 at the earliest – they will begin hearings on Pete Hagset, which could lead to his impeachment. Democrats do not currently have a majority.

The long-term problem with Hagset is whether he will be able to remain in office, given not only the eight articles of impeachment – which include allegations of war crimes in Venezuela, Iran, and Yemen, but also the purges of American commanders and officers, abuse of power, the dismissal of staff, and the irresponsible handling of information – the publication of what could have been classified data on apps like WhatsApp and Signal.

One could list everything he has done, but one of the reasons for the dissatisfaction with Hegset is that the war with Iran is going very poorly. This will likely remain a pressing issue in January.

I think there’s an immediate problem regarding the war with Iran: U.S. Vice President J.D. Vance doesn’t like Hegset and is trying to take control of U.S. policy and operations in Iran.

In an attempt to initiate negotiations with the Iranians, Donald Trump spoke out against this today, stating, “No, no, no, J.D. Vance does not control U.S. policy.” Does this mean that Pete Hegset is still one of the decision-makers, or has he already been sidelined?

As for Ukraine, in my opinion, things work differently there. I believe that Pete Hagset poses a threat to Ukraine.

He has repeatedly delayed aid deliveries to Ukraine since 2025. He doesn’t believe in European security, but on this issue, J.D. Vance also doesn’t believe in European security.

So right now we face a more immediate threat: Hegset remains in office for at least the next few weeks, but so do Vance and Trump’s new chief of staff, Stephen Miller. In other words, Ukraine will continue to have to deal with the Trump camp, which, if not openly hostile, is at least not on Ukraine’s side.

I’d like to add a few more things we need to keep an eye on, aside from Pete Hegset. If Marco Rubio, the Secretary of State, runs for president, he’ll have to step down from his roles as Secretary of State and National Security Advisor.

And although I am not a big fan of Marco Rubio and disagree with many of his actions regarding Ukraine, he is at least willing to listen to Europeans and Ukrainians on matters of security. If he leaves, who will replace him as Secretary of State, and will it be someone as destructive as Hegset or Vance?

If you find an error on this page, select it and press Ctrl + Enter

Advertisement
Adv