20 November, 11:00
19
Updated - 11:07, 20 November

Xi Jinping Outmaneuvered Trump and Belittled Putin: What Was Actually Decided at the Meeting in China

The trilateral meeting between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin in China might have given the impression that world leaders were about to define a new world order and agree on the future of global security. However, behind the summit’s high-profile facade lay a very different reality: Beijing demonstrated its dominance, Washington sought to use the meeting to advance its own political interests, and the Kremlin –

The trilateral meeting between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin in China might have given the impression that world leaders were about to define a new world order and agree on the future of global security. However, behind the summit’s high-profile facade lay a very different reality: Beijing demonstrated its dominance, Washington sought to use the meeting to advance its political interests, and the Kremlin aimed to secure at least symbolic recognition. But China is in no hurry to intervene in Russia’s war against Ukraine, as the current instability may be more advantageous to it than any agreements.

Political analyst Oleg Saakyan explained to 24 Channel why Putin found himself at the summit as a secondary guest, what China gained from the meeting with Trump and the Russian president, and why the trilateral talks did not become a new Yalta. The political analyst also assessed whether Trump is capable of forcing the Kremlin to end the war, why Russia is trying to draw Europe into security negotiations, and under what circumstances China might exploit the war in Ukraine for its own interests.

What initial conclusions can be drawn from the meeting between Trump, Xi, and Putin in China? Did the Russian president truly find himself in the role of the “third wheel,” or is this merely a superficial impression masking far more significant agreements? To what extent could this meeting influence the future world order, and are the decisions of these three leaders capable of shaping the geopolitical balance for the coming decades? And should we expect any real breakthroughs regarding the war in Ukraine – which all three leaders touched upon in their statements – given that Ukraine continues to demonstrate its ability to deal painful blows to Russia, particularly against strategic targets?

The most expensive photo op in Russian history. And I think that’s the key takeaway and the key intrigue: what did Putin pay for it?

For Xi, it was important to demonstrate that both Trump and Putin are coming to him. And with Trump – to show that the United States recognizes China and is coming to China. And with Putin – to demonstrate that he ranks below China, that he’s coming almost to bow down. That’s why the meeting formats differ: Xi personally welcomes Trump, demonstrating that these are two key capitals, while Putin is met by the fifth-highest-ranking official in China.

When Putin extends his hand, Xi pointedly does not shake it. In photographs, Putin is cropped out, and Xi’s wife is placed between him and Xi. A whole series of moments – some strictly protocol-based, some bordering on protocol, and some completely outside of protocol – demonstrates Russia’s secondary role at this summit. Putin's telling stance during the group photo was one such episode.

Political scientist on China’s covert diplomacy: video

China does not want to divide the world. It wants the whole world, and for China, spheres of influence lie not in territories but in sectors. It doesn’t matter to China whether it’s Latin America or Asia, except for the issue of Taiwan. What matters to China are high technology, open trade, the absence of sanctions pressure, and risk minimization.

For Xi, Europe’s lack of agency in the context of the Russia-Ukraine war is unacceptable, as is the violation of territorial integrity. China does not recognize any territories as Russian because it needs to ensure that Europe and the United States are not in the same boat. Trump is doing a pretty good job of this himself, undermining transatlantic unity.

Therefore, all this talk about Yalta is more of a narrative for the Russian media landscape, where propagandists will portray a meeting of three equal leaders. A comparison of the summit with the Yalta Conference holds special significance for Russian propaganda. But at the previous Yalta Conference, China was the object of politics, and for China, this is a deep trauma – how China was divided, exploited, and colonized by the West. China sees itself as an empire and a civilization, and therefore all these stages of the world’s division are humiliating to it.

That is why, even in terms of form, Putin was not allowed anything of the sort. At the banquet, he was seated separately from Xi and Trump. This is an asymmetrical meeting from the perspective of interests. There is no common interest, no common agenda – neither on nuclear issues, nor on security, nor on broader geopolitical matters, nor regarding the Russia-Ukraine war, nor even on Iran or the Strait of Hormuz. So there could be no new Yalta. It’s simply a photo op: for Putin – to puff out his chest; for Xi – to show that people are coming to see him; for Trump – to counter the negative publicity from the election campaign.

So who stands to gain the most from this meeting – Trump, Putin, or Xi?

Xi is the key beneficiary. For Trump and Putin, it’s about symbolic posturing, about the image. For Xi, it’s about concrete influence and concrete status.

The Kerch Bridge, of course, weakens Putin ahead of his trip. It’s not just a military-logistical operation, but also a moral, psychological, and political blow to Putin’s regime. The irony is that in Shenzhen, where the meeting is taking place, China is showcasing its engineering and architectural prowess, particularly the bridges built there. This is highly symbolic: I wonder what expression Putin will have on his face as he observes this marvel of Chinese engineering, thinking about the bridge that is now almost gone.

Could Trump’s outwardly friendly gestures toward Putin and the Russian president’s conspicuous discomfort during the meeting have masked a tough conversation about his last chance to reach an agreement? How realistic is it that Washington has already ramped up pressure on the Kremlin by limiting military support for Ukraine, and has now effectively forced Putin to choose – agree to peace or face new consequences?

It’s possible, but I don’t see any significance in such meetings. First, there has been no real change – neither geopolitical, nor regional, nor in the actual situation – in the context of the Russian-Ukrainian war as a separate theater of operations. Without a change in the variables in this equation, there will be no different outcome.

Second, Trump shows no flexibility in his approach – he keeps trying to repeat exactly the same thing. If Trump’s actions don’t change, the context doesn’t change, and Putin remains the same, then I wouldn’t expect a different outcome.

Third, what is the point of negotiating with Trump if he won’t oversee the implementation of any agreements? Trump might say: if we don’t reach an agreement now, Congress will step in and provide weapons. But what if they agree that Congress won’t provide weapons? What could force an end to the war on Russia’s terms right now? Ukraine understands that Congress will step in, and there will be different terms – and Ukraine will have a much stronger negotiating position than it does now. Not that it’s very strong, but it won’t be burdened by Trump’s attempts to hold Ukraine down by the ankles and drag it to the bottom, while lifting Putin onto his shoulders.

So when Trump makes statements like this, he doesn’t come across as serious. He lacks the resources and the ability to carry this out. Does he have the means to coerce Ukraine? No. Does he have any tough tools to coerce Europe? No. He doesn’t even have the tools within the United States to do whatever he wants anymore – the current Congress has shown him a red card following “Trump's decisions regarding Starlink, Starshield, Patriot, and intelligence data.”

Some Republicans in Congress and the Senate have already said they won’t support such moves. Trump finds himself in a “lame duck” situation when it comes to implementing agreements. The U.S. president is no weak figure; he can still accomplish a great deal in foreign policy, but he can no longer act arbitrarily for long. And to implement any agreements that would bring about an unjust peace – that is, a war on hold – he needs to make several consecutive moves, which he is no longer capable of doing.

For Xi, the key moment now is to squeeze everything he can out of Trump and demonstrate that it is Trump who is coming to Xi, and that Xi is the leader of the world. Similarly, for Putin, the meeting with Trump is an attempt to bargain for yet another reprieve and to create additional problems for Europe.

Why has Russia now started talking about non-aggression pacts with certain European countries and a European collective security system? Because this system will be shaped without Russia, and Russia wants to be at the table. It is trying to secure for itself the opportunity to participate in these negotiations.

Right now, Russia is taking advantage of the fact that Trump is saying, “Bring Russia to the table; let’s talk about European security.” At the same time, they’re telling Europe, “We’ll manage on our own somehow.” Russia, meanwhile, says, “And we can sign non-aggression pacts.” If there are weak links – countries where far-right radicals might come to power and sign such agreements – it would mean NATO is as good as dead, because different security approaches regarding the key threat in Europe would emerge within the Alliance.

In other words, Russia is trying to create points of tension and is using Trump as leverage while it still has him in its grasp. The goal is, if not to overturn the situation, then at least to seriously destabilize it and deepen the rifts within the Western coalition.

Is Xi Jinping truly interested in ending Russia’s war against Ukraine and willing to influence Putin, or is it more advantageous for China to maintain the status quo? To what extent do Trump’s statements about a shared desire with Xi to end the war reflect Beijing’s actual intentions, rather than being mere diplomatic rhetoric?

It is not in China’s interest at this time for Russia to end the war. China would benefit from a scenario of a protracted, low-intensity war that does not create additional threats to global security. But this is unrealistic in a conflict like the one between Russia and Ukraine. And at present, Russia is not sufficiently exhausted to settle for such an outcome or to end the war.

The scenario that might be acceptable – and even desirable – for China is currently impossible. Consequently, they are operating under the assumption that the war will continue, which is also not a bad outcome for China, although it carries risks that they must manage. For example, they want to ensure that nuclear weapons are not used, that the conflict does not spread further into Asia, and that it does not affect territories through which Chinese trade routes pass or where China has spheres of influence – such as Kazakhstan – and to ensure there is no large-scale mercenary activity or other consequences that China finds undesirable.

In all other respects, China is quite content with Russia’s weakening. The U.S. finds itself in a state of dependency because the war in Ukraine forces it to react, flounder, and become internally destabilized. Trump is undermining transatlantic unity and eroding trust in the U.S. as an ally in Europe, Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. All of this plays into China’s hands.

Now is the time to throw stones. The world order is crumbling; a new one has not yet emerged, and China does not want to take on obligations amid chaos, when those obligations will inevitably be violated one way or another. China is interested in unblocking the Strait of Hormuz, but even there it is not acting as a mediator, a guarantor, or the party that will use political or military force to open the Strait of Hormuz for global trade. Why? Because they see how Russia has become bogged down in Ukraine, and Trump in Iran. China doesn’t want to get bogged down anywhere. It wants to watch as others throw stones, and then simply pick them up when the situation ripens.

Should we expect China to take any concrete steps to resolve the war in Ukraine, the conflict in Iran, or the issue with North Korea, or is Xi Jinping currently just demonstrating his influence on global politics and the economy? To what extent is his current stance driven by a desire to strengthen his own trade and geopolitical interests, rather than to intervene in conflicts?

China is not interested in making any drastic moves at the moment. If it is offered something truly monumental – if a “white swan” or “black swan” event were to occur – then perhaps China might be capable of taking such steps. It has both the resources and the capabilities, and on all these issues, China has a say and knows which cards to play. But without extraordinary circumstances, it will not do so. It is not in its interest.

China is waiting for everyone else to dig themselves into an even deeper hole, and then, as a result, it will rise above the fray and be able to take advantage of the situation. When it comes to the Russian-Ukrainian war, China will not play this card with Trump – and most likely not even with the future U.S. administration. If it does play this card, it will be with Europe, because China needs access to the European market and wants to prevent Europe from siding with the U.S. in the event that China seizes or subjugates Taiwan.

I do not believe that China will do this through brute military force. But November and December are very critical months in this regard, as it is quite likely that by the end of this month or in December, we will see China’s first attempts to politically subjugate Taiwan. Local elections are taking place there, and China will try to take full advantage of them, since there are already more lawmakers in Taiwan’s parliament aligned with China than there are from pro-sovereignty or anti-communist factions.

For China, if it needs to intervene at all, it will do so only after the U.S. has completely dug itself into a hole, and only when the matter is being resolved with Europe. But Europe is not ready to let China into the European security framework. China itself will not defend Ukraine’s position. Although there is an irony in the fact that, under certain circumstances, China’s interests may turn out to be closer to those of Europe and Ukraine than America’s, in terms of a model for ending the Russian-Ukrainian war.

Do the differences in how Trump and Putin were received in China indicate a real disparity in their status in Xi Jinping’s eyes? How revealing are these diplomatic details – from the personal meeting at the airport to the format of the interactions and the attention given to each leader?

Putin is still taken seriously because of nuclear weapons. It is precisely because of the nuclear factor – and the fact that Russia could cause a great deal of damage – that he is received and met with. But this is done within a framework where he is an outsider, and every possible effort is made to demonstrate that he is an outsider.

Formally, it’s a meeting of three, but in essence, it’s a mockery of Putin. China has carried this out at various stages, using various symbols, and has demonstrated in every way possible that Russia is nowhere near China’s level, and that Putin is not on Xi’s level. Trump, on the other hand, is on the same level, and recognition from an equal is important to Xi and China. The United States, represented by Trump, is important to China, even if Trump himself comes across as a bit clueless.

At the reception, the inscription is in Chinese in capital letters, with English below. Where is Russian? Where is any other language? Learn Chinese. China welcomes China in capital letters, with English – the language of international communication – below, particularly in Trump’s presence. This is symbolic. The music played during Trump’s meeting and Putin’s meeting also carries symbolism. There were many different moments through which China demonstrated the different weight classes in which these two guests find themselves.

By the way, there were other guests there as well, but all attention is focused on the trilateral meeting, which is taking place for the first time in its current configuration and is perceived as something important. As for me, this is a completely inconsequential situation with no serious consequences or results. It’s simply a pay-for-play photo op for the three of them.