Views: Reading time: 17 min

Putin's Wild Fantasies: Why the Shenzhen Summit Is Unlikely to Turn Into a New Yalta Conference

Key points

  • On November 19, a trilateral meeting between the presidents of the United States, China, and Russia will take place in Shenzhen as part of the APEC summit, which has been compared to the 1945 Yalta Conference.
  • The meeting has different objectives for each participant: Trump is seeking a diplomatic victory, Putin aims to discuss the terms for ending the war in Ukraine, and Xi Jinping seeks to preserve China’s international influence.
APEC Summit in Shenzhen: What Putin Hopes to Gain from His Meetings with Trump and Xi

On November 19, a meeting between the presidents of the United States, China, and Russia is scheduled to take place in Shenzhen, China, as part of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit.

 
Adv

Some Western media outlets have begun actively comparing this meeting to the 1945 Yalta Conference. The argument goes that the leaders of the “great powers” will once again gather around the same table to divide the world into spheres of influence, just as in the “good old days.” Clearly, such an arrangement would be ideal for Putin, who makes no secret of the fact that he lives in the past.

However, despite the Kremlin’s hopes of agreeing on a new division of the world into spheres of influence, its counterparts appear to have entirely different plans. Trump is seeking a diplomatic victory in the wake of his defeat in the U.S. election, while Xi Jinping aims to consolidate China’s leadership position in the world. But even if the talks end with nothing more than rhetorical declarations, Putin will still have a reason to celebrate a victory.

popular videos

Advertisement

24 Channel examined what Trump, Putin, and Xi are actually seeking, why their interests do not always align, and what risks the upcoming meeting poses for Ukraine and Europe. And most importantly – can Shenzhen truly become a new Yalta, where the fate of smaller states will once again be decided without their participation? Dmytro Korniienko,founder of the Resurgramanalytical community, shared his expectations for the Shenzhen summit in a comment to 24 Channel .

A meeting between Xi, Trump, and Putin is a bad thing in and of itself. What makes it particularly troubling is that it was Vladimir Putin himself who proposed the idea for this summit on October 9, 2026, during a phone call with Donald Trump.

Advertisement

The Russian dictator proposed a trilateral meeting involving Xi Jinping at that time, and, as reported by The Wall Street Journal, the Kremlin’s goal was to push through an agreement to end the war in Ukraine on terms favorable to Moscow. Moreover, the presence of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy at these talks was not even discussed.

Trump and Putin during the summit in Alaska / Photo – Getty Images

According to the publication, it was during that same conversation that Trump and Putin agreed on the purchase of Russian diesel fuel and the easing of restrictions on the sale of Russian energy resources. For the U.S. president, who was seeking to lower fuel prices ahead of the midterm elections, this prospect seemed quite appealing. Putin, meanwhile, gained an opportunity not only to improve relations with Washington but also to use economic agreements to advance his own terms for Ukraine’s capitulation.

Advertisement

However, as it turned out, proposing a meeting to Trump proved much easier than actually organizing it. The Financial Times reports that U.S., Russian, and Chinese officials discussed a potential trilateral summit for three weeks. Moreover, Washington and Moscow effectively pressured Beijing, trying to convince the Chinese leadership to agree to the talks. Xi Jinping himself, however, did not seem eager to support the idea.

Steinmeier and Xi Jinping met in Beijing on October 30, 2026 / Photo – Xinhua

German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier offers a very telling description of Xi Jinping’s aloofness. Just the day before, he had been discussing a possible meeting with the Chinese leader, and, according to him, Xi appeared frankly perplexed, and discussing the Ukrainian issue “irritated” him. Moreover, the Chinese leader assured that he did not plan to discuss the war in Ukraine without European participation, since this issue directly concerns Europe.

Advertisement

Ultimately, after several weeks of negotiations, the parties agreed to hold the summit. On November 16, the Chinese Foreign Ministry officially confirmed that Trump, Putin, and Xi would indeed meet in Shenzhen on November 19, and even dubbed the upcoming talks an “event of breakthrough significance.”

However, behind this solemn rhetoric lies one rather significant problem. Even just a few days before the summit, the parties had still been unable to agree on a joint agenda.

Russia has consistently sought to discuss the Pechenegs and Ukraine, Washington has focused on nuclear disarmament, and China, for its part, shows little desire to discuss either the former or the latter. Thus, the peculiarity of this “historic” summit lies in the fact that none of the three leaders has yet determined exactly what will make it historic.

Advertisement

Despite the high-profile statements about the “historic” nature of the upcoming summit, each of the three leaders is heading to Shenzhen with their own agendas, which do not always align with the interests of the other participants. Moreover, it seems that Donald Trump has the highest expectations for the meeting.

Following the Republicans’ crushing defeat in the midterm elections, the U.S. president desperately needs at least some kind of diplomatic victory that he could present as a personal, historic achievement. This is precisely what Dmytro Kornienko emphasizes in his conversation with 24 Channel.

Dmytro Korniienko

founder of the analytical community “Resurgram”

As a president who has lost control of Congress – a fact that China understands very clearly and will exploit – Donald Trump is eager to demonstrate his influence and, above all, minimize the political fallout from this defeat, since foreign policy remains the purview of the White House. And demonstrating that Trump is conducting some kind of global negotiations with China will ultimately be portrayed in the press as a certain success for his administration. At least, that is how Trump himself would like to see it.

Advertisement

Thus, Trump’s main goal is a new nuclear arms control agreement involving the U.S., Russia, and China. In addition, Washington hopes to make some progress regarding the conflict with Iran, and assistance from Moscow and Beijing could help break the deadlock.

The summit in Shenzhen will mark the fourth face-to-face meeting between Trump and Xi during the U.S. president’s second term / Photo – Getty Images

Incidentally, the U.S. president’s schedule itself is quite telling. On November 19, Trump plans to hold separate talks and a working lunch with Xi Jinping, while no face-to-face meeting with Putin is scheduled at all. The White House has not explained the reasons for this decision, but U.S. officials emphasize that negotiations to end the war in Ukraine are being conducted separately, without China’s participation. Thus, it appears that Washington views Shenzhen primarily as a platform for reaching agreements with Beijing, while Russia has so far been assigned the role of a third party in negotiations on nuclear security.

Advertisement

Moreover, the White House makes little effort to hide its skepticism regarding this meeting. One high-ranking official in the Trump administration explicitly told reporters that the U.S. side does not expect any specific nuclear agreement to be reached during the summit. Therefore, despite all attempts to generate hype around the meeting, the United States is counting on minimal achievements – such as joint declarations, mutual commitments, and, likely, an agreement on the next summit.

For Putin, however, Ukraine remains the primary objective. The Kremlin seeks to persuade Trump to agree to Russia’s terms for ending the war – and, even better, to secure concessions without Kyiv’s direct participation in the discussions.

However, even if this does not happen, the very fact of meeting with the leaders of the U.S. and China will already be a significant political triumph for the Russian dictator. After all, Moscow will easily present this meeting as proof that Russia has supposedly regained its status as a superpower and is discussing the fate of the world at the same table with other major players. Dmytro Korniienko is convinced of this.

Dmytro Korniienko

founder of the analytical community “Resurgram”

Putin’s idea is to sell the U.S. and China on the concept of dividing the world into spheres of influence – hence the comparison to Yalta. However, China is unlikely to agree to these approaches from the Kremlin. To be frank, Moscow is currently Beijing’s junior partner, and if there is indeed to be a division of spheres of influence, it will primarily be between the Americans and the Chinese.

Moreover, the Russians aren’t even trying to hide their motives. For example, Alexander Dugin, the ideologue of Russian fascism, called the upcoming meeting “a confirmation of a multipolar world in which the main decisions are made by Russia, China, and the U.S.”

In addition, on November 12 in St. Petersburg, a painting by Russian artist Alexei Sergienko titled “Shenzhen-26,” depicting all three leaders, was even unveiled. This direct reference to the famous photo of Stalin, Churchill, and Roosevelt in Yalta perfectly illustrates how the Kremlin is already attempting to turn the summit – which has not yet taken place – into its own geopolitical victory.

Presentation of the painting “Shenzhen-26” in St. Petersburg / Photo – AP

While Putin rejoices and Trump “ponders deeply,” Xi Jinping, the host of the upcoming summit, faces a much more difficult situation. China is certainly interested in showcasing its international influence, but it definitely does not want to take on unwanted obligations.

This is especially true when it comes to nuclear disarmament, which Trump is banking on. According to rough estimates, the U.S. and Russia each have more than 5,000 nuclear warheads, while China has only about 600. Therefore, Beijing has absolutely no interest in agreeing to the same restrictions as the much more powerful nuclear powers.

Vladimir Putin and Kim Jong-un at a parade in Beijing / Photo – Getty Images

Moreover, Beijing is in no hurry to support Russia’s ambitions regarding Ukraine. Xi Jinping understands perfectly well that attempting to negotiate the future of a European country without Europe’s participation is unlikely to improve his relations with the European Union – one of the largest markets for Chinese goods.

But the Chinese leader also does not want to sour relations with Putin, as Russia remains an important source of energy resources and a political partner in the standoff with the United States. According to Kornienko, Beijing now has to balance its economic interests in Europe with its strategic cooperation with Moscow.

Dmytro Kornienko

founder of the analytical community “Resurgram”

When it comes to China’s own interests, this summit is based on the idea of affirming its political ambitions – essentially making a statement about China’s desire to assume full-fledged global leadership. In other words, Beijing views this summit in much broader terms than the Kremlin does – and, of course, than U.S. President Donald Trump will.

Ultimately, the situation is quite uncertain. Trump wants concessions from China on nuclear weapons, Putin is seeking American concessions regarding Ukraine, and Xi Jinping has little desire to agree with either of them.

So while all three are preparing for this “historic” meeting, the main question remains open: will they be able to agree on anything at all, aside from a group photo?

After all, the upcoming meeting in Shenzhen is causing the greatest concern not in Washington, Moscow, or Beijing, but in European capitals. After all, the very idea that the leaders of three major powers could discuss the future of Ukraine and European security without the participation of Europeans themselves brings to mind some rather unpleasant chapters in history. And that is precisely why Western journalists have already begun comparing the upcoming summit to the The Yalta Conference of 1945.

Leaders of the United Kingdom, the United States, and the USSR at the Yalta Conference, 1945 / Photo – Wikimedia

As a reminder, at that time, U.S. President Franklin Roosevelt, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, and Soviet dictator Joseph Stalin met in what is now occupied Crimea to agree on the end of World War II and the future structure of Europe. In particular, the leaders discussed the fate of Germany, Poland, and other Eastern European countries.

And although no formal decision was made in Yalta to divide the continent into Soviet and Western spheres of influence, after the war a significant part of Europe effectively came under Moscow’s control. Moreover, the Poles, Bulgarians, Romanians, Czechs, Slovaks, and Hungarians themselves were not particularly asked whether they were satisfied with such a future.

However, there is one fundamental difference between Yalta and Shenzhen. In 1945, Stalin already controlled a significant part of Eastern Europe thanks to the Red Army’s advance. Today, however, Putin not only does not control all of Ukraine but is also continuing the war, unable to take even Malaya Tokmachka and attempting to achieve by force what he could not obtain through diplomacy. Therefore, it would be premature, to say the least, to expect that Trump and Xi would simply recognize Russia’s right to dictate the fate of neighboring states.

However, this does not mean at all that Ukraine has nothing to fear. The main risk lies not even in the signing of some large-scale agreement, but in possible informal arrangements between Washington and Moscow. For example, Trump might agree to increase pressure on Kyiv to make territorial concessions, renounce NATO membership, or limit future security guarantees. Moreover, this would not necessarily require adopting a joint declaration or even officially including the topic of Ukraine on the summit’s agenda.

For Europe, the problem is even broader, because if Washington will begin discussing the future of European security with the Kremlin without the participation of its allies, this will only reinforce doubts about the reliability of American guarantees. This is especially true in Poland, Finland, and the Baltic states, which are directly facing the Russian threat and – like Estonia – are currently announcing border closures amid sabotage at defense plants.

The fact is that today Putin is demanding not only concessions from the U.S. regarding Ukraine; his ambitions extend to a significant part of Eastern Europe, and demands – such as withdrawing NATO forces to the 1997 borders – remain on the list of his key ultimatums to the so-called collective West.

Trump personally helped bring Putin out of international isolation / Photo – Getty Images

Incidentally, Poland has already openly spoken out against playing into Russia’s hands. On November 16, Polish Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski proposed holding a trilateral summit involving the U.S., China, and the European Union instead of a meeting between Trump, Putin, and Xi. According to the diplomat, the current format of the talks unjustifiably elevates Russia’s status to that of a global superpower, which it has not been for a long time. Sikorski also emphasized that to end the war, the West must increase pressure on Moscow rather than demand further concessions from Ukraine.

Dmytro Korniienko

founder of the analytical community “Resurgram”

Sikorski’s proposal is an attempt to block the Russian initiative and offer an alternative. While Moscow seeks to organize negotiations in a Russia–China–U.S. format, the Polish minister proposes replacing Russia with the European Union. In this way, Europe could retain influence over decisions that directly affect its future. However, the question remains as to whether Sikorski carries enough political weight to speak on behalf of the entire European Union, and whether the Trump administration would even accept such a proposal.

Ultimately, a new Yalta-style summit in Shenzhen may not happen, but that does not mean Putin will come away empty-handed. After all, for the Kremlin, the very fact of a meeting with Trump and Xi will already serve as proof that Russia is once again perceived as one of the key players in world politics.

And while Ukraine and Europe fear deals being struck behind their backs, the Russian dictator will have the opportunity to establish as a fact that, without him, no agreements are possible in principle. So, Putin’s main victory in Shenzhen will likely be precisely that he won’t even need a single signed agreement to achieve it.

FAQ

If you find an error on this page, select it and press Ctrl + Enter

Advertisement
Adv