Views: Reading time: 23 min

"Only a madman could have come up with this": Ogryzko on the US plan to change the borders of Donetsk Oblast

Volodymyr Ogryzko on Negotiations with Russia

Washington and Moscow continue to discuss possible agreements to end the war, including a proposal to change the administrative boundaries of the Donetsk region. Meanwhile, Europe is seeking its own format for participating in the negotiations, and in Ukraine, the issue of dependence on U.S. military aid is becoming increasingly acute.

 
Adv

Former Ukrainian Foreign Minister Volodymyr Ogryzko appeared on 24 Channel to explain why he considers U.S. proposals regarding Donbas absurd and how the new composition of Congress might influence Donald Trump’s policies. He also assessed the prospects for European defense independence, the possibility of international recognition of occupied Crimea, and the controversy surrounding Europe’s future representative in negotiations with Russia.

popular videos

Isn’t Ukraine at risk of becoming a bargaining chip in negotiations between the U.S. and Russia? Could Washington and Moscow reach an agreement at our expense?

Advertisement

We are currently witnessing coordinated efforts between Washington and Moscow. This is a foreign policy process that is unfolding quite actively, and its participants are trying to advance their own interests. But I see one positive development: on January 3rd, the new U.S. Congress will take office. I believe that after that, the Trump team’s ability to operate as it has been will be significantly curtailed.

In the United States, there is already discussion of upcoming reviews of the activities of representatives of the presidential administration. This involves potential hearings in congressional committees, investigations, and legal assessments of specific decisions. In particular, questions may arise regarding Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, who are involved in contacts with Russian leadership. As long as Trump controls the political process, they feel quite confident, but as Congress’s role strengthens, the situation may change.

Advertisement

Witkoff and the son-in-law are prime targets for the Democrats to turn into punching bags. As long as Trump was in charge, they were able to act. If he stops being in charge, they’ll have to answer for their actions– Ogryzko suggested.

I expect the new Congress to take a much closer look at the activities of the American negotiators. Especially if questions arise regarding their potential private interests or the compliance of certain decisions with U.S. law. But it’s important to understand that this is still a prediction, not the established findings of any investigations.

In my opinion, the Americans and Russians are trying to resolve their own issues at Ukraine’s expense. The most striking example is the idea of changing the administrative borders of the Donetsk region. The idea is to formally assign the territories that Russia was unable to capture to other Ukrainian regions. Then the Kremlin could declare that it controls the entire Donetsk region, even without advancing any further on the front lines.

Advertisement

Only a madman or someone on the path to madness could have come up with this. I can’t interpret it any other way– said the former foreign minister.

Let’s suppose we agreed to such an arrangement, and Putin announced that he had fulfilled his promise to capture the Donbas. But why not do the opposite and assign occupied Donetsk to the Dnipropetrovsk region? This demonstrates the sheer arbitrariness of such an approach. Administrative renaming of territories does not change the very fact of the Russian occupation and does not resolve any of the causes of the war.

There is also a much more serious contradiction. Russia has enshrined in its constitution claims not only to the Donetsk region but also to other Ukrainian regions. It has fully occupied Crimea, but it does not control the Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions within their administrative boundaries. Even if we imagine the withdrawal of Ukrainian troops from the rest of the Donbas, what should be done with the other territories that the Kremlin has also declared Russian?

Advertisement

The American proposal does not answer this question. It attempts to create an opportunity for Putin to declare victory on one issue, but ignores the rest of his territorial claims. Therefore, I do not understand how such a plan could serve as the basis for a genuine cessation of hostilities.

If you want us to retreat and hand over part of the Donetsk region to them, but forget about the other regions that are allegedly already enshrined in the Russian constitution, is that okay with you? There’s no consistency here. There’s only one logic: money, money, and more money– Ogryzko emphasized.

I suppose that financial interests may play an important role in the actions of certain American officials. But even if they want to reach certain economic agreements with Russia, that doesn’t mean Ukraine should agree to territorial concessions. Especially since Putin himself shows no willingness to back down from his previous demands.

Advertisement

Therefore, I do not consider the Trump team’s current shuttle diplomacy to be promising. I have said before that these may be the last such trips for Witkoff and Kushner, after which their attention will be focused entirely on other matters, specifically explaining themselves to U.S. lawmakers. I wouldn’t rule out the possibility that there won’t be any new substantive rounds of negotiations at all by the end of the year.

This is Witkoff and the son-in-law’s final tour. And then their tours will be primarily directed toward Congress – to testify and explain why they were involved in thisthe diplomat speculated.

The only area where I would like to see continued contact is the humanitarian one. Prisoner exchanges are necessary regardless of political disagreements, and it’s worth supporting such negotiations to bring our people home. But as for a comprehensive settlement, there’s nowhere to go for now, since Russia has no intention of changing its demands.

Advertisement

I also expect new attempts by the current U.S. administration to put pressure on Ukraine. These could take the form of restrictions on access to Starlink, military supplies, or other forms of support. However, I believe that the scope for such pressure may narrow once the new Congress takes office.

The White House has proposed to the Kremlin that they discuss a new security system for Europe – but without Europe itself. Does this mean that Ukraine’s security interests will not be taken into account in such agreements?

You’ve correctly identified the key point: the U.S. administration is proposing that Russia shape a security system for Europe without fully involving the Europeans themselves. But I see another danger here. In this framework, the issue of Ukraine’s security is effectively sidelined, even though it is our country that is currently directly confronting Russian aggression.

Advertisement

In my assessment, the approach being discussed by Washington and Moscow reflects a desire to restore Russia’s significant influence over Ukraine. The Russian proposals presented during the 2022 negotiations in Istanbul may serve as a reference point. At that time, Moscow put forward demands that would have substantially limited Ukraine’s defense capabilities and effectively created conditions for the Kremlin to maintain control over our country.

It is anticipated that Russia will restore its full influence over Ukraine. And to achieve this, it is using as a model what Russia brought to Istanbul in 2022. Everything is laid out there– Ogryzko believes.

I view this model as extremely dangerous. It would mean that the fate of Ukraine is once again being decided by states, one of which has waged war against us. And worst of all, in this process, the U.S. administration, in my opinion, is prepared to take Russian interests into account far more than Ukrainian ones.

This does not mean that the entire United States supports this course of action. We must distinguish between the current White House and other American institutions, particularly Congress. But if we assess the actions of Trump’s negotiating team specifically, I see in them a trend that is dangerous for Ukrainian statehood.

How should Ukraine proceed if the current U.S. administration effectively agrees to some of Russia’s demands? Under such circumstances, shouldn’t we reconsider our relations with the United States?

I wouldn’t phrase the question quite so sharply. Even with my critical stance toward Trump, I understand that our relationship is not just with him personally, but with the United States of America. It is a much broader system that includes Congress, political parties, government institutions, and society. And it would be a mistake to abandon cooperation with the entire country because of the actions of a single president.

We understand perfectly well that we cannot simply sever these ties right now. If Ukraine already had all the necessary military technology, its own missile defense capabilities, and independent communications systems, the situation might be different. But for now, a significant part of our security remains tied to American capabilities, so we have to seek compromises and maintain contact even under very difficult circumstances.

We cannot just slam the door right now and say, “Goodbye, United States of America; we’ll manage without you.” If that were possible, I think we would have done it long ago. But for now, we’re forced to dance this tango with Donald Fredovich– explained the former foreign minister.

A recent humanitarian operation in Oleshky serves as an example of difficult decisions. To bring people home, we had to engage in negotiations involving representatives from both the American and Russian sides. We managed to rescue several hundred Ukrainians, and this is an important achievement that should not be downplayed. At the same time, I would like to draw attention to new threats facing Kherson, where people are also having to be evacuated due to the security situation.

Therefore, Ukraine is forced to strike a balance: to make use of current opportunities for cooperation with the U.S. while simultaneously minimizing its dependence on the U.S. as much as possible. And this is already happening not only in political statements but also in specific defense projects.

In particular, the Ukrainian president’s meeting in Copenhagen with representatives of the Nordic and Baltic states was significant. In this context, plans were announced to test the first version of the FREYJA system this winter, which is expected to become a more affordable alternative to some of the systems currently used for missile defense. If these plans are implemented, Ukraine will gain additional defense capabilities without having to constantly rely on American Patriot missiles.

Intelligence data and satellite communications remain equally important. Europeans and Ukrainians have finally realized how dangerous it is to depend on a single provider of critically important services. Therefore, we need to develop our own or joint European systems that cannot be restricted by a political decision in Washington.

Now people in Europe – and finally in Ukraine – have realized that relying on a single source ends up costing more. And that’s right. We need our own communications system and our own anti-ballistic defense– Ogryzko emphasized.

Ukraine is already developing its own ballistic missile program, although its scale does not yet meet all the military’s needs. At the same time, Europe is gradually coming to understand that independent defense requires not only increased military budgets but also its own technologies, industrial capacity, and space capabilities.

And here I see a certain paradox. We often criticize Trump for his decisions, but it is precisely his policies that are forcing Europe to change its attitude toward its own security. Just two years ago, European countries largely assumed that the American military umbrella would remain in place forever. Now they are increasingly considering the possibility of providing for themselves independently.

We will have to thank Trump for helping Europe achieve the unimaginable – something they wouldn’t have even considered just two years ago. Now Europe is emerging not only as an economic power but also as a military and military-political forcethe diplomat noted.

In my opinion, this process could become one of the most important consequences of current U.S. policy. European states are beginning to reassess their role in international security and are gradually creating the capabilities they have lacked since the end of World War II.

Once again, claims are being made that Russia allegedly would not have launched a full-scale invasion in 2022 if Joe Biden had guaranteed that NATO would not expand. But Russian aggression against Ukraine began as early as 2014. Isn’t this rhetoric an attempt to permanently sideline the issue of the occupation of Crimea?

That’s unrealistic. All temporarily occupied territories remain Ukrainian, and no political agreement between third countries can automatically change their legal status. We must distinguish between the actual situation – where a certain territory is temporarily controlled by Russia – and its status under international law as part of Ukraine.

Even countries that maintain relations with Moscow are in no hurry to recognize its territorial claims. One might mention Kazakhstan, which declares its respect for the territorial integrity of states, or Turkey, which also upholds this principle. Therefore, talk of a possible permanent annexation of Crimea by Russia does not correspond to the position under international law held by Ukraine and many other states.

None of the civilized nations recognizes a single square centimeter of the occupied territory as belonging to Russia. There is a de facto and a de jure situation. We are waiting for the moment when the actual situation changes– Ogryzko emphasized.

Of course, foreign policymakers may express various assumptions regarding the prospects for the return of Ukrainian territories. In particular, the NATO Secretary General may have his own assessment of how quickly Ukraine will be able to regain control over the occupied regions. But such statements do not mean that anyone has the right to make decisions on behalf of the Ukrainian state.

If Ukraine does not recognize the occupation, no leader of an international organization can force it to change its position. Political assessments may differ, but the issue under international law remains unchanged. And I have not heard NATO leadership openly renounce the principle of territorial integrity of states.

If we determine that under no circumstances will we recognize the occupation and do not accept the logic that what is occupied is Russian, then no secretary general or anyone else can change this situationthe diplomat explained.

Therefore, I see no reason to believe that new negotiations could legally cement Russian control over Crimea without Ukraine’s consent. Temporary occupation does not nullify our sovereignty, and decisions regarding the future of Ukrainian territories must be made by Ukraine itself.

Emmanuel Macron has stated his readiness to represent Europe in dealings with Russia, but the Kremlin criticizes Europeans for lacking a single negotiator. Can the French president fulfill this role, and how important is it for Europe to finally decide on its representation?

First and foremost, one simple thing must be understood: it is not up to Moscow to decide who will represent Europe in the negotiations. European states can send a single politician, several leaders, or a large delegation. This is exclusively their right, and Russia should not determine its composition or make demands regarding specific candidates.

The Ukrainian delegation, for example, also consists of more than just the people journalists see in official photographs. There are front-row representatives, advisors, experts, and other participants who facilitate the negotiation process. Similarly, Europe can assemble its team according to its own needs.

It is not up to Moscow to decide who will be in the European delegation or how many people will be there. There could even be ten. This is determined by the party forming the delegation. No one else can say that they don’t like someone– Ogryzko emphasized.

However, Europe itself really needs to decide on its representation. Previously, Kaja Kallas, Gitanas Nausėda, António Costa, and other European politicians had expressed a willingness to play such a role. Now Macron is talking about it. But every such initiative sparks controversy, and in the end, the European Union is left without an agreed-upon format for participation.

I don’t think European leaders are fighting over any specific material benefits. Rather, it is a matter of political ambition and prestige. Representing the European Union in negotiations to end the continent’s largest war is an extremely important role. It can significantly influence the future political career of the person who assumes it.

In this context, Macron’s interest is understandable. His presidential term is nearing its end, and the war is unlikely to end at the same time as his term in office. Therefore, participating in the negotiations could become a distinct international political priority for him.

There’s really nothing else at stake here. It’s simply a matter of ego: I was elected by the European Union, and I will represent such a powerful entity in the negotiations. This is a serious and prestigious undertaking– says the former minister.

But I wouldn’t reduce European representation to a single person. It would be much more effective to form a group of three to five influential politicians representing the continent’s strongest states. And it shouldn’t be limited exclusively to members of the European Union, since the United Kingdom is also a European nation and plays an important role in supporting Ukraine.

Such a delegation could have a single leader, but politicians of roughly the same caliber should work alongside him. This would allow for the interests of several key nations to be taken into account and make Europe’s position more representative.

“I would form a proper group, perhaps headed by a single person. But among the colleagues, there should be people of the same high European political caliber. And why should we forget about the UK? It is not an EU member, but it is a European country,”Ogryzko explained.

The main thing is that the members of such a delegation represent a previously agreed-upon position. It’s not enough to simply choose a well-known politician and send him to the negotiations. If he starts pushing his own ideas without consulting other countries, Europe will once again face internal conflicts.

What if Europe forms a negotiating team of several leaders but offers the leadership role to Volodymyr Zelenskyy? Wouldn’t that send a powerful signal of support for Ukraine and serve as a response to Russia’s attempts to exclude Ukraine from shaping the continent’s future security?

I don’t think such an arrangement would work. Ukraine has its own delegation and its own negotiating position, which is represented by its leadership. The European Union, for its part, must independently determine who will speak on its behalf. We are not yet members of the EU, so we cannot claim the right to lead its official delegation.

Of course, our security is directly linked to the security of European states. If Ukraine can ensure lasting peace and protect itself from new Russian aggression, this will have a positive impact on the entire continent. But such interdependence does not negate the separate powers of Ukraine and the European Union.

That’s a bit unrealistic. How can we take away the European Union’s right to determine for itself who represents it? Unfortunately, we are not yet members. We have our own delegationOgryzko explained.

The European Union and NATO already have an established practice of acting on their own behalf in international negotiations. They can coordinate positions with Ukraine, synchronize their actions, and support our demands, but they should not transfer the right to represent these organizations to the leadership of another state.

Therefore, I believe the optimal option is to have two separate but closely coordinated delegations. Ukraine must defend its own national interests, while Europe must present a unified position on the continent’s security. Most importantly, these positions must not contradict one another and must not allow the Kremlin to exploit differences among partners.

Volodymyr Ogryzko on U.S.-Russia negotiations: watch the video

If you find an error on this page, select it and press Ctrl + Enter

Advertisement
Adv