"This is a public slap in the face": Sharp on the strike on the Crimean Bridge
The strike on the Crimean Bridge dealt a serious blow to Russia’s logistics. David Sharp explained how the bridge was hit, what role Starshield might have played, and what the risks are of attacks on bridges in the Rostov region.
Following a new strike on the Crimean Bridge, the road section of the crossing sustained serious damage, while the Russians managed to partially restore rail traffic. At the same time, Ukrainian strikes on bridges in the Rostov region pose additional risks to the land corridor through which Russia supplies its troops in the occupied south of Ukraine.
Military analyst David Sharp explained on 24 Channel why the extent of the damage to the Crimean Bridge came as a surprise to him and what it means for Russian logistics. He also assessed the possible use of video-guided munitions during the attack, the role of the Starshield satellite communication system, and the prospects for further strikes on Russia’s transportation infrastructure.
The Crimean Bridge has been put out of commission for an extended period
According to OSINT analyst Dnipro OSINT Garbuz, following the strike on the Crimean Bridge, the main arch span of the road section – over 270 meters long – collapsed, and adjacent railway sections were also damaged. How important is this crossing for Russian military logistics, given the existence of a land corridor through the occupied territories?
The Crimean Bridge is important in many respects, although it does not currently play a major role in military logistics. As for the possible consequences of the collapse of the structures for shipping in the Sea of Azov, there is one factor for the Russian side: shipping there is already virtually nonexistent due to Ukrainian strikes and drone operations.
But the actual outcome of the attack really surprised me. I had assumed that destroying the road section of the bridge would be a much more difficult task. After the first strike, I even said that Ukraine might simply be demonstrating its ability to disrupt traffic across the crossing or launching a protracted operation that would gradually create serious problems for the Russians.
However, it turned out that a relatively small amount of ammunition could achieve a much greater result. And this does not necessarily involve extremely heavy weapons. Judging by the nature of the damage, precise strikes on particularly vulnerable points of the structure were decisive.
I was very surprised; my initial assessments did not quite pan out. As it turned out, with a relatively small number of munitions – not necessarily extremely heavy ones – hits in specific locations effectively put the road bridge out of commission for a very long time. This is a tremendous success from a military standpoint,
– said Sharp.
It is precisely the precision of the strikes that makes this attack exceptional. In my assessment, TV-guided munitions were used, which could ensure hits on the desired sections of the bridge. Otherwise, to achieve a similar result, it would likely have been necessary to deliver a significantly larger number of strikes over an extended period of time.
The first consequence is enormous economic losses. The construction of the Crimean Bridge cost Russia a great deal, and the restoration of such complex engineering structures will also require significant resources. But no less important is the disruption of transportation links with the occupied peninsula.
Now, people who previously traveled to or from Crimea by car are forced to find alternative routes. Ferry service is an option, but it comes with additional risks and restrictions. Another option is a land corridor through the occupied territories of Ukraine, specifically the Mariupol area, but this route is also vulnerable to Ukrainian strikes.
It is important to remember that Russia previously restricted the movement of trucks and large vehicles across the Crimean Bridge for security reasons. As a result, its role in current freight transportation was less significant than it could have been. However, if necessary, these restrictions could be revised – for example, in the event of serious difficulties on the land route.
When problems arose with the land corridor, the Crimean Bridge option was always available, even if it wasn’t fully utilized. Now this is of immense importance,
the military analyst explained.
Thus, Russia has lost not only an important transport crossing but also the ability to use it as a backup route. The consequences could be particularly severe if, at the same time, problems arise with shipments through the occupied south of Ukraine.
There is also a political aspect. For years, Russia has invested enormous resources in defending the Crimean Bridge: it deployed air defense systems, strengthened its defenses against surface and submarine threats, and established additional defensive lines. However, these measures failed to protect the structure from a new Ukrainian strike.
This is a very serious public humiliation for the Russian authorities, including within the country itself. It is a demonstration of powerlessness. In the fifth year of the war, when it would seem that everything possible had already been done to protect the bridge and ensure its air defense, the enormous resources expended failed to deliver results,
Sharp emphasized.
For the Kremlin, this situation is particularly damaging on the eve of international meetings involving Donald Trump and Xi Jinping. Russia is trying to demonstrate its military might, but at the same time cannot guarantee the security of one of its most important symbolic structures. This affects the perception of its capabilities not only within the country but also abroad.
At the same time, it is important to distinguish between the consequences of strikes on the road and rail sections of the bridge. As far as I understand, President Zelenskyy reported the use of heavier weapons against the railway infrastructure, specifically “Neptune” and “Flamingo” missiles, as well as “Ruta” drone missiles. I also classify the latter as a type of cruise missile.
Despite this, the railway section was not completely destroyed. At the time of our conversation, the Russians had already restored traffic on at least one of the two tracks. The road bridge proved to be significantly more vulnerable to direct hits, while the rail bridge, even after the use of heavy weapons, continued to function partially.
The railway bridge, unlike the road bridge, is still functioning to some extent at this point. Apparently, the operation on the road bridge was very successful, while the railway bridge initially proved more challenging. However, the outlook here is clear,
– Sharp noted.
I also view this strike as a kind of response by Ukraine to Russian attacks on bridges in Kyiv and other infrastructure facilities. For a long time, the opportunity to deliver such a serious strike against the Crimean Bridge was not utilized for political reasons. Now, on the eve of winter, as Russia continues to attack Ukraine’s rear areas, this tool could become part of broader pressure on Moscow.
I do not rule out that the strike could also be significant for negotiations regarding a possible energy truce or mutual restraint on attacks against rear-area targets. The railway section of the bridge has not yet been completely disabled, and its future fate could theoretically remain a subject of negotiations. Another explanation is that Ukraine is simply demonstrating the price Russia will have to pay for continuing its strikes on Ukrainian infrastructure.
Restoring the road bridge will also be a challenging task. Even if Russia finds the necessary equipment, manufactures new structural components, and begins repairs, the risk of repeated attacks will remain. Given Ukraine’s current capabilities, rebuilding the crossing without guarantees that the attacks will cease could turn into a never-ending cycle of repairs, with the structure repeatedly coming under threat.
Attempting to rebuild the road bridge without a ceasefire or a moratorium on strikes against these locations would be a very thankless task. Otherwise, it would be better not to even try, or to solve the air defense problem that Russia has failed to resolve in five years,
the military analyst explained.
Of course, this attack is very painful for Putin, so it may further intensify his desire to strike Ukrainian targets. But it would be wrong to claim that any subsequent Russian attacks will occur solely because of the damage to the Crimean Bridge. The Kremlin already had sufficient motivation to continue the strikes, and Russia has been carrying them out systematically.
How “Flamingo” and Starshield Might Have Been Deployed
For over a week prior to the strike, speed restrictions were in place for Starlink and Starshield in the occupied territories. At the same time, Zelenskyy reported a guided strike using “Flamingo,” and footage allegedly taken from aboard the missile appeared online. Could such an attack have taken place without Starshield, and how was precision ensured?
Yes, in principle, it is possible. We are seeing footage presented as video from aboard a specific munition. It could have been “Flamingo” or another weapon system. However, we cannot completely rule out the possibility of an information and psychological operation, so the mere fact that the video was published does not allow us to determine exactly which technologies were used.
Theoretically, the strike could have been carried out without video guidance. If the coordinates of the bridge’s vulnerable sections were determined in advance, and Russian electronic warfare systems failed to create effective jamming, the weapon could have hit the target precisely using satellite navigation.
Theoretically, all of this could have been accomplished without video guidance – for example, by precisely striking designated points using GPS. If the enemy failed to create interference, a strike based on map coordinates could be very accurate,
Sharp explained.
But the published materials allow us to consider another scenario. Perhaps, by the time of the attack, Starshield’s operations had been restored to a mode that allowed the system to operate at higher speeds. Or more sophisticated, specialized communication capabilities were employed, which differ from the standard operating mode of satellite terminals.
Here, it is important to consider the speed of the delivery vehicle itself. Speed limits of 160 kilometers per hour or lower are suitable for relatively slow, aircraft-type drones. But cruise missiles and their variants travel much faster. Consequently, if Starshield was used to guide them, the usual limitations could not have remained unchanged.
Either Starshield’s operating speed was increased, or some more complex, specialized capabilities were utilized. Such technical solutions exist,
the military analyst noted.
One possible option is real-time flight correction during the terminal phase. This allows the operator not only to direct the weapon toward the target area but also to refine the point of impact immediately before the strike. This is particularly important for a complex engineering structure, as its various elements have different levels of vulnerability.
Video link can also allow monitoring of the flight path right up until the final moments before impact. This does not yet constitute a full assessment of the damage after the explosion, but it does make it possible to see whether the munition has reached the intended section of the structure.
There are technical solutions that allow operators to adjust the strike at the last moment via video feed and select the exact target point. The operator understands where he is striking and can see, right up to the last fraction of a second, that he is on target,
Sharp explained.
It’s also important to note that Ukraine’s video-guided capabilities do not necessarily depend entirely on Starlink or Starshield. Under normal conditions, these systems operate over Ukrainian territory and the occupied regions, but coverage near the Russian border may be limited. However, the Ukrainian military has already demonstrated strikes using video guidance at significantly greater distances.
In particular, such capabilities were employed during attacks on Russian ships in the Caspian and Baltic Seas. This indicates the existence of technologies that enable communication and strike adjustments beyond the usual operational zones of the aforementioned satellite systems. This does not mean that such solutions are already being used in all long-range operations, but they are available for specific complex missions.
The Ukrainians have certain capabilities for video-guided strikes, and they are being utilized. Perhaps not on a massive scale, but they are available for specific strikes. And here, of course, special capabilities could have been deployed if necessary,
– the military analyst emphasized.
Therefore, I would not definitively attribute the success of the attack solely to the resumption of Starshield’s operations. Several technologies may have been employed, and without access to the technical details of the operation, it is impossible to determine the specific mechanism used. At the same time, the precision with which the road bridge was struck indicates a very high level of preparation and execution of this mission.
Strikes on the Rostov region threaten the occupiers’ logistics
Along with the Crimean Bridge, another bridge in the Rostov region – located on the route to the land corridor leading to occupied Crimea – was also targeted. How important are these crossings for supplying Russian troops in southern Ukraine, and could such attacks escalate into a systematic campaign against the occupiers’ logistics?
It is precisely in this context that I would first and foremost consider the military significance of the strikes. The issue at hand is the supply of Russian forces in the occupied south of Ukraine. Over the past few days, there have been reports of several isolated but quite effective attacks on bridges in the Rostov region, particularly across the Mius River.
However, it is important to understand that the significance of different bridges varies. I have not conducted a detailed intelligence analysis of every crossing in the region, so I would not attempt to determine their importance based solely on the fact that they were struck. But it is clear that there are transportation facilities in Rostov itself upon which the operation of major logistics routes depends.
If Ukraine seeks to disrupt connections from the Taman Peninsula and the Krasnodar Krai, the Crimean Bridge becomes the primary target. However, the supply of Russian forces, as well as a significant portion of commercial freight, is primarily carried out via a land corridor through the occupied territories.
Consequently, the bridges in the Rostov Region may be of particular importance for Russian logistics. This applies primarily to rail transport, as railways allow for the movement of large volumes of cargo. I consider the railway bridge in Rostov to be one of the key targets in this context.
But the mere fact that even an important crossing has been damaged does not mean that the enemy’s logistics have suffered a strategic blow. Russia can organize repairs, change the route, or temporarily reroute shipments. Therefore, the consequences of isolated attacks often remain limited.
Occasional strikes on small bridges are painful jabs. But sustained strikes, putting them out of commission for an extended period, and preventing their restoration – that is an approach that can yield truly significant, long-term results,
Sharp explained.
If key crossings are systematically targeted, Russian forces will be forced to constantly expend resources on repairs, seek detour routes, and alter their supply chains. If problems arise simultaneously on the Crimean Bridge and the land corridor, the ability to shift cargo between alternative routes will also be reduced.
Therefore, what will be decisive is not the number of bridges struck in a single night, but the duration of the disruption to their operations. A systematic campaign against key transportation hubs has the potential to create significantly greater difficulties for Russian forces than isolated successful attacks, after which the enemy quickly restores traffic.
Sharp on the strike against the Crimean Bridge: watch the video