Онлайн Редакція Вакансії Контакти Ігри Гороскоп
20 November, 16:00
6

The Trap of a Humanitarian Pause: Why Russia Is Lying About the Capture of Kostiantynivka and Begging for a Ceasefire

Key points
  • Russia claims to have captured Kostiantynivka, but fighting for the city continues, and the situation on the front lines does not match these claims.
  • The five-day humanitarian pause being promoted by the Kremlin could give Russian troops time to consolidate their positions and prepare for a further offensive.

Russia continues to claim that it has captured Kostiantynivka, even though fighting for the city is still ongoing and its territory has turned into a complex network of Ukrainian and Russian positions. The Kremlin is pushing for a five-day humanitarian pause, which is supposedly intended to help evacuate civilians. However, such a ceasefire could play into the hands of the occupiers: giving them time to move into the city, regroup, and prepare for a further offensive.

Russia continues to claim that it has captured Kostiantynivka, even though fighting for the city is still ongoing and its territory has turned into a complex network of Ukrainian and Russian positions. The Kremlin is promoting the idea of a five-day humanitarian pause, which is supposedly intended to help evacuate civilians. However, such a ceasefire could play into the hands of the occupiers: giving them time to move into the city, regroup, and prepare for a further offensive.

Russian opposition journalist Michael Naki explained to 24 Channel what is actually happening in Kostiantynivka, why the Kremlin’s claims about capturing the city do not match the situation on the front lines, and how drones have changed the nature of the fighting. The journalist also explained why Russia needs a humanitarian pause, what threats it poses to Ukrainian defenses, and why holding positions for the sake of reports can lead to the exhaustion of troops.

Despite the loud claims by Russian leadership and propagandists about an alleged 'capture of Kostiantynivka,' the reality on the front lines is radically different. The battle for the city has been going on for a year now, and it remains a zone of active combat.

As Oleksandr, an officer with the Main Intelligence Directorate’s unmanned systems unit, notes, Russian troops are constantly attempting to infiltrate the town in small infantry groups. They search for weak spots in the Ukrainian defenses, moving from cover to cover.

However, there is virtually no classic line of contact there. Instead, a sort of layered structure has formed, consisting of Ukrainian and Russian positions.

What’s happening near Kostiantynivka: see the map

The nature of the fighting has changed so much that infantry on both sides are often ordered not to engage in direct firefights. The main goal is to avoid exposing their positions to enemy drones.

The sky over Kostiantynivka is teeming with drones, which have become the primary weapon of choice. There are instances where Ukrainian and Russian troops occupy different parts of the same building, using different entrances, which makes it impossible to accurately map the situation. Ukrainian military personnel have also spoken about how the front line has shifted due to the large number of drones.

The greatest threat under current conditions is Russia’s attempts to impose so-called humanitarian pauses. Denys Yaroslavskyi, an officer with the Joint Forces Rapid Reaction Command of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, emphasizes that halting hostilities – even for a few days – would be a fatal mistake.

Russia is deliberately promoting the idea of a five-day humanitarian pause, ostensibly to evacuate civilians. In reality, however, the occupiers need this time solely for military logistics.

Interestingly, Putin is seeking to initiate a so-called "humanitarian mission" in Kostiantynivka in the Donetsk region. However, Ukrainian officials warn that the Kremlin could use the ceasefire to covertly redeploy equipment and reinforce its positions, as has already happened in Oleshky. Furthermore, Russian claims of controlling the city are untrue, and the Ukrainian side is not preparing any such operation at all.

If the fighting stops, Russian troops will immediately enter the city, hide in basements, bring in additional units and ammunition, and lay mines throughout the area. Currently, the main advantage of the Ukrainian defenders is that they are destroying Russian infantry and equipment even as they approach the city.

In open terrain, the enemy is vulnerable to drone and artillery strikes. However, if the Russians are allowed to enter the urban area unimpeded, it will be extremely difficult to dislodge them from there due to the abundance of cover. In particular, the ISW has revealed the possible purpose of the Russian ceasefire – to create conditions for reinforcing troops and launching a further offensive.

Last summer, when Vladimir Putin prematurely announced the capture of Kostiantynivka, there were only about 100–200 Russian soldiers in the city. The infiltration of even this small number of occupiers during a hypothetical ceasefire could seriously weaken the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ defensive capabilities and tip the scales in favor of the aggressor.

The northeastern part of the city remains under secure Ukrainian control, where UAV operators are based. The rest of the territory has turned into a continuous gray zone. The Ukrainian military reported on the situation in Kostiantynivka and Russian attempts to advance toward the city.

Intense fighting is also taking place in the Rusyn Yar area, which is a key element of Ukraine’s defense. The enemy is attempting to seize the high ground for a further offensive, but the Ukrainian Armed Forces are blocking these attempts.

The situation is complicated by the fact that Ukrainian troops are forced to hold their positions under extremely difficult conditions. Due to the constant threat from the air, the evacuation and rotation of personnel are practically impossible.

Some soldiers have been stationed in the southern part of the city for over a year. The practice of holding territory to the very end for the sake of reporting requirements is leading to the exhaustion of units.

There remains hope that the new command will change its approach to defensive operations, prioritizing the preservation of soldiers’ lives over formal control of devastated settlements that have long been unfit for civilian life.

Russian opposition journalist on the Kremlin’s plan at the front: video