Trump Won't Be Able to Make Concessions to Putin: Pincus Explained What Has Changed in the US
Boris Pincus explained why Donald Trump is seeking a meeting with Putin in China, how the new U.S. Congress could limit concessions to the Kremlin, and whether it is possible to end the war along the front lines. He also discussed the strikes on the Crimean Bridge and military aid to Ukraine.
Donald Trump's meeting with Vladimir Putin in China comes after the US congressional elections, which have significantly limited the American president's political options. At the same time, the Kremlin is trying to use international negotiations to return Putin to the circle of influential world leaders, despite Ukrainian strikes on Russian targets and the continuation of the war.
Public figure and president of the Ronald Reagan Republican Club, Boris Pincus, explained on Channel 24 why it will be more difficult for Trump to agree to the Kremlin's demands and what role Congress and his inner circle will play in this. He also assessed the possibility of stopping the war along the front line, Washington's reaction to the strikes on the Crimean bridge, and the situation surrounding further assistance to Ukraine.
Trump can no longer ignore Congress
In China, Xi Jinping has shown Putin his place, while Donald Trump wants to meet him face-to-face. Why does the American president want such a meeting, and what might they discuss?
We are also closely monitoring how Trump behaves towards Putin. Let me remind you, this is their first meeting since that infamous meeting on August 15, 2025, on the red carpet in Alaska. A lot has changed since then, so it is important to look not only at the handshake or the words of the American president, but also at the circumstances in which he finds himself today.
So, could Trump try to bring back the "spirit of Anchorage" and organize a kind of "Anchorage 2" in China?
Quite possible. But let's look at the realities. Since then, a lot of water has flowed under the bridge, and it has been different - both muddy and transparent. During this time, a lot of events have occurred that have changed the position of Trump himself. His behavior, of course, worries the American political elite, but today he is no longer in such a free position as before.
First of all, this is due to the results of the elections on November 3. In my opinion, Trump has suffered a complete failure and has lost a significant part of his influence on Congress. The new composition of the legislative body will begin work on January 3, 2027, and there is very little time left before that. And this is the first thing that affects the decisions of the American president today.
The second factor is threats from the Democrats and a change in the behavior of the Republicans, in particular the wing of the party that focuses on the political legacy of Ronald Reagan. Many of them no longer feel the same dependence on Trump, because the next major election cycle will take place in 2028. Then the entire House of Representatives and a third of the Senate will be re-elected again, and Trump's presidential term will gradually come to an end.
Today, a significant number of congressmen who have already taken off their masks are clearly joining the moderate Democrats who are categorically against Trump's foreign policy, especially regarding Ukraine,
– Pincus emphasized.
A draft bill has already been prepared to provide Ukraine with bipartisan assistance in the amount of $15 billion. I emphasize: this is aid, not arms sales. And the fact that such an initiative has the support of representatives of both parties is extremely important for Ukraine.
According to the election results we are talking about now, Democrats could win 56 seats in the Senate, and Republicans could win 44. This is a very significant change in the political balance. The Senate is involved in resolving financial issues, including those related to aid, and also approves or rejects the nominations of judges, ambassadors, and members of the presidential cabinet. Therefore, Trump will have to take its position into account.
And now let's get back to how the American president is behaving in China. You rightly noted the contrast between his attitude towards Putin and the behavior of Xi Jinping. Trump shows much more favor to the Russian dictator than the Chinese leader.
Meanwhile, Xi Jinping had already met with Putin about an hour before he met Trump at the airport. They talked for about an hour or even an hour and a half and spoke out against the sanctions and tariff policies of the American president. This is understandable, because trade wars and restrictions have negatively affected both China and Russia.
But that's not the most interesting thing. What matters is how Xi Jinping treats Putin in front of journalists and the Trump team. Beijing demonstrates its attitude towards the Russian dictator publicly, while the American president continues to show affection for him.
There is another very important point that has not yet been fully revealed, but which we are closely following. It concerns Steve Miller, who has been given an extremely influential role in Trump's entourage. Previously, he was associated with national security issues, and now, according to the information we have, his powers have increased significantly.
His influence could extend to staff appointments, the formation of foreign delegations, and the preparation of the president's meetings. Even Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who has a close relationship with Steve Miller, will be in the decision-making system that he can influence. So it is important for us to understand what position Miller will take on Ukraine.
Steve Miller has never spoken negatively about aid to Ukraine. We haven't seen him do that. At the same time, it will depend on him who Trump will meet with, what appointments will be made, what delegations will go abroad. Most likely, it will also depend on Steve Miller regarding Ukraine,
– explained the public figure.
Just this morning, one of my sources suggested that Steve Miller might take a positive stance on Ukraine. There have even been allegations that he personally has a negative attitude towards Trump. But for now, these are just talks, and I don’t want to present them as established fact. We have to see how possible changes will manifest themselves in the specific actions of the American administration.
Miller is unlikely to remain neutral. He could become a kind of "gray cardinal" or an open supporter of a fairer political course. There are also rumors that Trump may even sacrifice Pete Hegseth for the sake of agreements with the Democrats. There are still many events ahead that could affect the composition and behavior of the presidential entourage.
But let's get back to the meetings in China. I don't expect an immediate breakthrough from them. At the same time, it is important that Trump and Xi Jinping meet in the context of two major wars: Russian aggression against Ukraine and a war related to Iran, which may escalate even more. The Chinese leader cannot remain aloof from these processes.
Putin, of course, would love to present his participation in the negotiations as a historic event. There are even comparisons that he wants to be in the role of Stalin in 1945, when Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin sat at the negotiating table. The Russian dictator would love to demonstrate to his own population that he, together with Trump and Xi Jinping, is deciding the fate of the world.
This is especially important for him now, as Ukraine continues to strike at Russian targets. We see attacks on the Crimean bridge, oil refineries, fuel shortages, and lines at gas stations. In my opinion, all of this is fueling discontent within Russia, and Putin needs to project an image of international success to his people.
It would seem that it would be great for Putin to show the world: look, things are not so bad for us. I am sitting here with Trump himself, with Xi himself. We are deciding the fate of the world. Like hell! From the very beginning, Xi Jinping showed Putin his place,
– said Pincus.
But then another question arises: why does Trump himself show a much more favorable attitude towards Putin than the host of the meeting? Literally half an hour before our broadcast, I discussed this with a person whose assessments I listen to very carefully. I am often critical of Trump's behavior, but my interlocutor advised not to rush to conclusions.
He pointed out that Trump's position has become much worse since the election. There are threats related to investigations and possible prosecution of representatives of his administration. Therefore, even if Trump would like to continue to play along with Putin, political circumstances no longer allow him to act as freely as before.
They tell me: cool your ardor, don't exaggerate so much. Trump is not a tsar, he can't do whatever he wants. He won't be allowed to do it even if he wants to. Trump can't play give-away with Putin today,
– said Pincus.
Of course, I still have questions about the behavior of the American president. Why has he continued to play along with Putin in recent months? Why hasn't he implemented the specific sanctions he himself has talked about and allowed for the possibility of economic contacts with Russia?
For example, there was a story with two tankers that were transporting Russian diesel fuel to the United States. According to the information we discussed, it was bipartisan opposition that prevented these deliveries from being made. The tankers changed course and headed for Brazil. After that, talks about such deliveries stopped.
Trump, meanwhile, has continued to make statements about possible territorial concessions by Ukraine. But I am told that his current game may ultimately not work in Putin's favor. If he meets with the Russian dictator in China, he will most likely talk about ending the war along the current front line.
Why? Because it's not just Volodymyr Zelensky who is categorically against the transfer of Ukrainian territories to Russia. Europe also supports Ukraine, and Trump cannot simply ignore the position of his European partners.
We are also seeing some changes in the distribution of foreign policy authority in the US administration. Trump has reportedly stopped J.D. Vance's initiative to hold talks with representatives of the Iranian leadership on a possible ceasefire. Instead, he is handing over foreign policy to Marco Rubio, who has repeatedly stressed the importance of Europe for international security.
Rubio and Vance's positions on Europe differ significantly. And today, Europe and Ukraine have a common position on Putin's demands. This means that the American president must take into account not only his own desires, but also the positions of his partners and the new Congress.
Therefore, I am inclined to the opinion of those experts who do not expect Trump to make major concessions to Putin. Even if he wants to do this, it will be extremely difficult for him. Moreover, he himself is interested in agreements with Congress, because he has to resolve issues related to political threats to him and his entourage.
I don't expect the meeting in China to end with the signing of any major agreements. There will most likely be no breakthrough. But a positive thing could be the discussion of reducing the nuclear potential of the three largest nuclear powers. Trump himself is already raising this issue.
In addition, despite previous statements from his entourage, Ukraine will still be among the topics of the negotiations. Trump himself announced before his departure that he was planning a separate conversation about Ukraine. And, as far as I understand, this applies to both contacts with Xi Jinping and a possible meeting with Putin.
Putin may be asked to stop the war on the front lines
Witkoff and Kushner reportedly warned the Kremlin that the terms of the peace deal could worsen for Russia after the congressional elections. Could Trump use this in his negotiations with Putin and propose a deal now?
The concession we can talk about is what Volodymyr Zelensky has already voiced. It is about freezing the war along the current front line. That is what a concession is. But the Kremlin has not yet accepted this option and continues to demand that Ukraine hand over the entire Donbas to Russia.
Listen, it doesn't matter what Putin wants. The situation has changed, and now he has to take into account not only his demands, but also the political processes in the United States. After November 3, time, in my opinion, began to work against the Russian dictator.
Putin has no choice, and time is no longer working in his favor. Until now, time has been working for him, and now, after November 3, it is working against him. This is Trump's main trump card today against Putin,
– Pincus emphasized.
The American president can explain to Putin that he still has some ability to influence the negotiations. But after January 3, when the new Congress begins work, his freedom of action will be significantly limited.
In essence, Trump could suggest to the Russian dictator that he at least stop shooting and agree to freeze the war. He could do it in his usual style - with compliments, pleasant words, a demonstration of personal affection. I don't really care about the form, if it really allows us to achieve the result.
Let him achieve some result with sweet words and compliments, as Trump knows how to do to all the dictators of the world, not just Putin. Today, we are satisfied with freezing the front line to stop the shooting. That's what we want. Let him start with that,
– explained the public figure.
By the way, Xi Jinping also, according to Chinese media reports, advocates stopping the war in Ukraine. And this is very important, because China has significant influence on Russia. At the same time, the issue of Ukraine is closely linked to events in Iran and the Persian Gulf.
Iran has recently significantly increased the production of missiles and drones. We are talking not only about the number, but also about the development of certain types of weapons, in particular ballistic missiles. In my opinion, Russia is helping Iran in this direction. According to available reports, both American and Israeli intelligence agencies are talking about such support.
So we see how interconnected these conflicts are. Xi Jinping is not interested in the war in Ukraine and the situation in the Persian Gulf escalating at the same time. For China, this creates serious economic and political risks.
Much will depend on Donald Trump's ability to convince the Chinese leader that cooperation with the United States is more beneficial than continued support for authoritarian regimes. But to do that, Washington will have to offer Beijing something concrete.
Of course, the biggest gift for Xi Jinping would be Taiwan. However, as far as I understand, this topic is not on the agenda of the negotiations. And rightly so, because the Taiwan issue has existed for many years, while the wars in Ukraine and around Iran require an urgent solution.
Trump has other leverage over China. First of all, these are trade tariffs, which he can significantly reduce. If today, according to the estimates we are discussing, they range from 25 to 50%, then a reduction, for example, to 15% would be extremely beneficial for Beijing.
Next year, China will have important political developments within the Communist Party. I have no doubt that Xi Jinping will maintain his position, but he also has internal opponents. And it would be very important for him to demonstrate an improvement in the economic situation.
Look at the economic growth rates of neighboring countries. India is showing GDP growth of more than 5%, the Philippines is about 6%, and Vietnam is also developing. Against this background, the Chinese economy, according to the estimates I am talking about, is growing more slowly than its leadership would like. In addition, China has serious problems in the real estate sector.
It is no coincidence that Elon Musk arrived in China with Trump. His companies may expand production on Chinese territory, in particular, Tesla factories. Previously, there was discussion of the possibility of transferring part of the production to India, which Beijing, of course, would not want.
In addition, there are issues of cooperation in the fields of artificial intelligence, high technology, and space development. All of this is of significant interest to China and could be part of broader agreements with the United States.
I believe that Trump has good leverage that he can use to cut off the main oxygen of the Putin regime. This is China. It is China that can stop the war in Ukraine today in one fell swoop. With just one call, one word: stop it, I'm tired of it, stop it. And that's it. We have high hopes for this,
– said Pincus.
But I don't expect it to happen on November 19. This meeting could be just the beginning of the process. I would like to hope that it will lead to an end to the war this year, perhaps in December. But that is just a hope, not a guarantee.
It is about ending hostilities along the current front line, without handing over Ukrainian territories to Russia. Not a single inch of land needs to be given up because of Putin's fantasies about changing the political borders of Europe.
The Kremlin continues to make old demands, in particular regarding Ukraine's membership in NATO, the presence of Alliance troops near Russia's borders, and other issues of European security. There are even absurd ideas about Finland and NATO. But all this is a thing of the past, such approaches do not correspond to the current situation.
Therefore, a possible personal conversation between Trump and Putin will be important primarily because of whether the American president can convey the new circumstances to the Russian dictator. We need to see what he tells Putin about ending the war, Ukrainian territories, and Russia's future relations with the West.
Trump still has illusions about cooperation with the Kremlin
There is a version that the US could have restricted the work of Starshield, knowing about the preparation of the Ukrainian operation against the Crimean bridge. Why can Washington still react negatively to Ukraine's strikes on objects that are symbolically important to Putin?
The trouble is different. Donald Trump still has illusory plans for economic cooperation with the Putin regime in his head. I have repeatedly said that as long as people like Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are around him, talks about possible business agreements with Putin will not stop.
Do you think they just go to negotiations? Of course not. These people are constantly coming up with ideas about the possibilities of cooperation with Russia. There is oil, gas, the Arctic, oil and gas infrastructure, as well as Nord Stream. They continue to think about how these resources could be used for joint economic projects.
There is also the European oil and gas infrastructure, part of which was previously connected to Russia. From here arise various fantastic plans about possible agreements and the division of economic interests. I do not believe that these projects will be implemented, but such ideas, in my opinion, still exist in Trump's environment.
As long as there are Witkoffs and Kushners like that, business relations with dictator Putin will remain in force. That's the whole problem. Putin has oil, gas, the Arctic. There is Nord Stream, which can be used. There are many fantastic plans that will never come true, but these people still have them in their heads,
– explained Pincus.
Just look at how some American representatives behave during their trips to Moscow. They agree to accept symbolic gifts, take photos in jackets with the words "Russia" written on them, and demonstrate a kind of affection for the Kremlin that I find completely unacceptable. After all, these are wealthy and influential people who should understand who they are dealing with.
And against this background, Trump continues to offer Putin certain prospects for economic cooperation. He says, agree to our conditions, and then we will develop something together, return Russia to international formats and open up new opportunities. I consider such plans to be disconnected from reality.
US Deputy Secretary of Defense for Political Affairs Elbridge Colby stated that Ukrainian strikes deep inside Russia do not stop its troops, but only unite Russian society. How do you assess this position, given the constant Russian attacks on Ukraine?
These are remnants of the old Trump policy that existed before November 3. But now it will no longer work the way it used to. Congress will not allow the American administration to pursue such a course unhindered.
We know Trump's character well. He supports the strong. And that is why Ukraine's attacks on the Crimean bridge can change his tone towards our state. The American president cannot ignore the fact that Ukraine is demonstrating its own military and technological capabilities.
We know Trump's character. He supports the strong. Ukraine's attacks on the Crimean bridge are changing Trump's tone. He can't ignore it. Absolutely not,
– Pincus emphasized.
Ukraine is showing today that it is capable of independently developing weapons and conducting complex operations. In particular, we are talking about the strikes on the Crimean bridge, which, as it is claimed, were carried out without the use of American Starlink. This demonstrates that our capabilities are not limited only to Western assistance.
And if the Russians try to resume the crossing, Ukraine, I believe, will have the opportunity to continue its operations. Trump understands this. He has already positively assessed the successes of the Ukrainian military, and these words cannot be separated from what is happening now.
The American president is also aware of Ukrainian developments in the field of countering drones. Ukraine is ready to sell or exchange its own technologies, in particular for missiles for Patriot systems. These are extremely promising anti-drone solutions that may be of interest to the United States.
All of this, along with the changes in Congress, gives me reason to look to the future with some optimism. I also don't think that Xi Jinping, after talks with Trump, will not show a desire to discuss ending the war in Ukraine.
There are experts who believe that China is interested in continuing wars in Europe and the Middle East so that the United States is forced to spend resources on them and pay less attention to the Pacific region. But I disagree with this assessment.
I don't think so. Xi Jinping is a very smart politician, he understands perfectly well that today we have reached a point that may become irreversible. We need to end this war with Putin,
– said the public figure.
In my opinion, the Chinese leader could offer Trump broader economic agreements. For example, lowering American tariffs, access to microchips, high-tech and artificial intelligence developments. In return, the parties could work together to end the wars in Ukraine and the Persian Gulf.
I would really like the negotiations to develop in this direction. And if Trump himself does not come to such a decision, perhaps his entourage, in particular Steve Miller, will suggest a similar path to him. After all, the internal problems of the US and international conflicts are closely related, and the American president will have to think about his political legacy.
I believe that it is worth starting at least with the cessation of hostilities along the current front line. After that, we can talk about further steps. I don't see any other realistic option for quickly stopping the shooting right now.
Meanwhile, more and more influential politicians in the Republican Party are openly criticizing Trump. For example, Senator Tom Cotton, who has considerable influence in the party, sharply opposed negotiations with Putin. He questioned how one could negotiate with a person he calls a criminal.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis is also showing similar sentiments. I consider him one of the potential future leaders of the Republican Party. I even find the possibility of a political tandem of Marco Rubio and DeSantis interesting. Both, in my opinion, can play an important role in the further development of the party.
I personally attended a political event where DeSantis was present. We discussed many issues, from the economy to the future of the Republican Party. And I see that changes are taking place within the party that could have positive consequences for Ukraine and Israel.
Therefore, today I am optimistic, although I do not expect a breakthrough from the talks on November 19 in China. They may initiate a process of de-escalation of the international situation, which will largely depend on contacts between the leaders of the world's two largest economies - the United States and China.
The fight for military aid to Ukraine continues in the US
According to NBC News, Republicans may try to remove provisions for military aid to Ukraine, intelligence transfers, and new sanctions against Russia from the 2027 U.S. defense budget. Could support for Ukraine really become a partisan bargaining chip in Washington?
I don't believe in such a scenario. Such reports may appear quite often, but one must look at the real political possibilities of the parties. Even if individual Republicans want to make such changes, I doubt that they will be able to do it before the end of the current Congress.
You say that the final text of the bill can be approved as early as the first week of December. But the Democrats have their own agenda, their own political priorities and plans. And even being in the minority until the end of the year, they are able to resist decisions that they consider unacceptable.
This is not true, my friends. Such rumors will appear very often. Even if the Republicans wanted to, they would not have time to do it by the end of November-December. The Democrats also have their own program, their own plan,
– Pincus is convinced.
I would also like to draw attention to Republicans who have consistently supported Ukraine. One of them is Brian Fitzpatrick, an extremely important figure in American politics. He participated in the preparation of initiatives aimed at restricting US trade with Russia.
In particular, there was discussion of creating a new legislative mechanism that would prohibit the Trump administration from expanding economic relations with Moscow. But the question arose as to why adopt a new law if there are already restrictions in place that were introduced back in 2022. In my opinion, it is necessary to ensure compliance with existing regulations first.
I have already mentioned the story of the tankers carrying Russian diesel fuel. According to the information we have, it was the existing restrictions and political opposition that made it possible to stop their supply to the United States. This is an example of how Congress and existing legislation can really influence the decisions of the American administration.
Therefore, I would not take every publication about a possible aid cut as a final decision. The American media is also interested in the attention of the audience, and reports about political conflicts attract readers and viewers. But it is necessary to distinguish political rumors from already made decisions.
Aid to Ukraine is authorized by Congress. How can they cancel it now? They can't, they won't get the necessary number of votes. And I don't believe that can happen. I absolutely don't believe that,
– said the public figure.
As for Mike Johnson, I don't think he will necessarily take such steps. In general, he has repeatedly demonstrated a positive attitude towards Ukraine. Of course, there was a very difficult period in 2024, when the provision of American aid was delayed for about six months.
Then Johnson, in my opinion, played into Trump's hands, and that became a serious problem for Ukraine. We remember how difficult those months were and what losses the Ukrainian military and civilian population suffered. I believe that later he realized the consequences of that delay.
But now Johnson's position is also changing. If he leaves the post of speaker, his dependence on Trump may decrease. He must think about his own future political career, as well as how he will be viewed by voters and religious communities.
Johnson is an evangelical Christian, and this is an influential part of American society. I drew attention to reports of a significant decline in Trump's support among evangelicals. According to estimates, it could have fallen to 17%, although these data, of course, must be viewed in the context of specific polls.
For many American believers, the issue of war against Ukraine is not only political but also moral. They see the suffering of the Ukrainian population and the destruction caused by Russian aggression. Therefore, supporting politicians who are willing to play along with the Kremlin may become increasingly problematic.
Trump is not supported today because, as these people say, he ignores the lives of true Christians, who are Ukrainians. And Putin is destroying Christianity in the heart of Europe. That is the opinion of evangelicals. And Johnson will not be forgiven for this if he continues to play along with the aggressor,
– Pincus emphasized.
Therefore, I do not expect that the issue of military aid to Ukraine can simply be used as a bargaining chip between parties. The political situation in Washington has already changed, and after the new Congress begins its work, these changes will become even more noticeable. I hope that this will allow support for Ukraine to be strengthened and limit the possibilities of those who still count on agreements with Putin's Russia.
Pincus predicted how the Trump-Putin meeting would end: watch the video