Онлайн Редакція Вакансії Контакти Ігри Гороскоп
21 November, 20:00
29

"Putin Is Scared": An Interview with Bogdanov on the Kremlin's Hysteria and the Failed Meeting in China

In an exclusive interview with 24 Channel on YouTube, political analyst and strategic communications expert Yuriy Bogdanov analyzed Vladimir Putin’s outburst following his visit to China and his fear of the G20 summit.

On his trip to China, Vladimir Putin apparently expected to gain much more than just a group photo (and an unsuccessful one at that) with Donald Trump and Xi Jinping. However, instead of demonstrating an equal partnership, the Russian dictator found himself in the role of a junior ally on whom Beijing does not particularly depend. And while the Kremlin is trying to portray the meeting as a diplomatic success, its subsequent statements only reinforce the impression of frustration.

At the same time, Moscow continues to threaten the West, issue ultimatums regarding NATO, and call on European leaders to negotiate. Against this backdrop, Ukraine is stepping up its strikes on Russian military and energy infrastructure, while the question of U.S. support for Kyiv remains open.

Political analyst and strategic communications expert Yuriy Bogdanov, in an exclusive interview with 24 Channel, discussed the true outcomes of the meeting between Trump, Putin, and Xi Jinping, the prospects for negotiations, the future of Ukraine’s relations with the U.S., and how the Russian dictator is gradually losing his leverage.

We’re approaching Shenzhen. But what did Putin really want from both of them? Just to show off in front of the cameras?

It’s obvious that Putin is in a state of total hysteria because he achieved nothing in China – obviously because Trump can’t offer anything, and Xi doesn’t want to. And we’re hearing more and more of these pompous and stupid statements from him, along with more and more intimidation, because he’s powerless on the battlefield and even among his own people.

His visit and his presence there were essentially a gesture of friendship from Trump, because he couldn’t accomplish any real objectives there. It was Trump who wanted to bring Putin along, obviously to try to demonstrate, “Look what a friend he is to me; let’s be friends together.” And then there was that disgusting statement of his that “Putin is my friend, and we’ll work everything out.”

Well, we’ve heard that before. It seems to me that the very way the Chinese received Putin demonstrates just how much he was needed there, just how much they wanted to see him. It was a rather humiliating reception and a humiliating escort – clearly treating him as a junior partner who is heavily dependent but, at the same time, unable to back down.

Full interview: watch the video

What did Trump want? To make the statement they issued afterward? It seems to me it said: “We will increase the supply of petroleum products to the global market.” Well, go ahead and try. According to the latest statistics, following a series of strikes in October and November, Russia has already lost half of its oil refining capacity. And it’s clear that the strikes by the Defense Forces will continue, and no one will stop them. The U.S. doesn’t have the tools to do so at the moment.

And it’s clear that if Putin isn’t willing to make any concessions regarding an energy truce or a ceasefire in general, then there’s no point for Ukraine to make concessions regarding its strikes. We’ll continue them and keep striking, because we see that peace talks are possible only under one condition: if Russia and Putin lose faith that they can achieve any goals in Ukraine and Europe by military means, then negotiations are possible.

Right now, we see that Putin is making a lot of cringe-worthy statements, inviting Europeans to Moscow. By the way, I can imagine that they’ll go to Moscow – it’s no problem for them to go there and present their own ultimatums to him.

But we’ll see. Because it seems to me that right now – especially after Ukraine’s latest strikes – and I’m not even talking about the Crimean Bridge, but rather the oil refineries and Russian logistics – the Russians don’t have many cards left to play. They will, of course, continue their terror campaign, but Ukraine will be able to at least minimize the consequences of that terror.

Putin says he’s inviting Europeans to discuss both European security and ending the war in Ukraine. I’m surprised that you say Europeans will actually go. I’m not surprised that there are people who definitely want to go to Moscow and who, in general, treat the Kremlin like their own home. But still, would people of the caliber of Kaja Kallas or Ursula von der Leyen really go to Moscow?

Kaja Kallas and Ursula von der Leyen certainly won’t go, of course, but certain diplomats and emissaries might very well go – if it’s part of the preparations for some kind of negotiations on neutral ground. In other words, I believe that Putin could have been conducting real negotiations long ago, for example, in Istanbul or Dubai, or anywhere else, or in Astana, for example, if Kazakhstan agreed to host such talks and Ukraine and Europe agreed to go there. There are various ways this could happen.

But the issue is that Putin is still making unrealistic demands: NATO as it was in 1997, and Finland’s withdrawal from NATO. Let’s remind everyone that Finland was not a member of NATO before the start of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. It was Putin himself who provoked this process. As long as these conditions remain on the table, there is no point in meeting anywhere, because these are unrealistic conditions that are clearly being put forward to derail the negotiation process.

But if Putin stops taking this stance, if reasonable conditions emerge, if there is an understanding of how, in principle, to resolve relations between Russia and Europe, and this begins with ending the war and showing remorse, then negotiations are possible anywhere, including, to some extent, in Moscow.

But as of today, it seems to me that Putin isn’t ready for negotiations. He continues to feign stupidity. Although why feign it? Not feigning, but taking a stance that’s quite unusual even for someone of his stature.

And it’s obvious that he’s very angry following the talks in Shenzhen. This is evident from his rhetoric and his statements: as soon as he realizes that something has gone wrong, he resorts to two tactics – terror and an incredible level of “posturing,” with claims that we’ll defeat everyone, overcome everyone, and take Ukraine in three days. Well, we’ve seen this before. In other words, it means something is wrong.

Yes, at this press conference he said, more or less, that Ukrainians need to accept the obvious – that the Donbas, those percentages of territory, will definitely end up under Russian control. This, of course, sounds ridiculous. It sounds unrealistic. But he keeps saying it so confidently – this “showing off,” as you put it. So I don’t understand who this is aimed at.

Obviously, his inner circle. It seems to me that Europeans understand this, and Putin can’t rely on Trump. And Trump’s own emissaries there have already conveyed Kushner’s message that he told the Russians: if you don’t strike a deal now, the situation will be worse for you after the change in the composition of Congress.

And this is an obvious message that, on the one hand, is intended to put pressure on Russia, and on the other hand, reflects reality. Because unlike Witkoff or Trump himself – Kushner, whoever he may be – is certainly corrupt, but he’s no idiot. You can definitely say that About Jaredhe’s corrupt – a very smart financier who’s simply stating the political reality that if Putin doesn’t reach an agreement now, things will get worse.

And his terror campaign this winter isn’t giving Russia any more chances. It’s creating more risks for Russia because, first of all, Ukraine is already fighting back this year – and in terms of actual economic damage, it’s even more effective than Russia. And in terms of political damage, again, yes, Russia is investing a lot of money in demoralizing Ukrainians and in making sure everyone would abandon everything and demand peace from Zelenskyy due to power outages.

But it seems to me that most of the people who are really driving this war – who are really driving the economy – are only becoming even more determined to put pressure on Putin, because everyone understands that he understands only the language of force and only the language of truth.

At the same time, Ukraine is carrying out successful strikes on the Crimean Bridge, and an international article is published afterward – later republished by The Times – stating that Ukraine carried out these strikes without Starlink or Starshield. In your opinion, is this really a very serious geopolitical signal, a shift in perspective, or is it perhaps a specific message to Washington?

It seems to me that the main point is a demonstration of the Defense Forces’ capabilities – that Ukraine can plan and carry out such a complex operation – and that is the best message. Because yes, Putin will bomb the bridges in Kyiv – and once again, to the esteemed residents of Kyiv, to those who live in the same city as you and me, I send my warmest regards. The bridges in Zaporizhzhia and Dnipro, for example, are bombed regularly. In Zaporizhzhia, it’s been constant – literally for the past few years.

And Russia, of course, is causing damage and inconvenience, but that’s part of the war. We’ll have to adapt to this. But the Russians are spending more time and more resources with fewer results. And we understand why we’re doing this – why we’re destroying Crimean bridges, crossings, ferries, and so on. We’re cutting off the Russian war machine, which is stationed in Crimea and in southern Ukraine, from its supply lines.

And this will allow Ukraine to defend itself better. Russia is destroying bridges for humanitarian reasons. And so, it seems to me, we are demonstrating the difference in our approaches. And it’s clear that Ukraine is showing that, with sufficient financial resources, it is capable of fighting even without the Americans. The main thing is that we have the money and weapons to strike back at the Russians.

But will there still be such a steady flow of funds and weapons in 2027?

It seems to me that yesterday Ursula von der Leyen stated that “ Allocation of 45 billion for Ukraine ” is essentially a settled matter, and we will be counting on European funding. Other partners will provide the remainder that we need. In other words, we’ll cover the budget shortfall. That’s the first point.

Second, systematic efforts are still underway to ensure that Ukraine receives all the necessary types of weapons that we can purchase in Europe. And these development programs continue to be implemented. It seems obvious to me that we will receive everything we need, and I believe we will be able to use it in the war against Russia.

Yes, Russia is still pinning its hopes on the idea that after some election, France will fall away, Germany will fall away, but even a hypothetical Marine Le Pen will most likely have to adapt to the political reality. In other words, as of today, I really don’t see any serious threats from Europe. There might be some: Bulgaria has dropped out; they said they wouldn’t help us. But Bulgaria wasn’t helping us anyway. It mainly sold us weapons and hasn’t stopped doing so.

The same goes for Slovakia. Slovakia didn’t help us; it sold us weapons and continues to do so. Let’s not even mention Serbia. After all, they’re Russia’s “big brothers.” But even under Vučić, Serbia sold us weapons, and it will continue to sell us weapons now. So, to be honest, I understand that Russia will do everything possible to prove that everything is “lost” for Ukraine.

But in reality, as of today, in my opinion, there is no threat of a disruption in funding or supplies to Ukraine. And so I think that, in principle, Russia needs to realize that if they want to emerge from the war more or less with their dignity intact, they will not succeed in breaking Ukraine, nor will they succeed in breaking Europe. They need to come back to the negotiating table. Will Russia be ready for this? I don’t know, but it’s high time for them to think about it.

Given that Putin says they’ve supposedly invited European diplomats – perhaps not at the highest level, as you say – to visit Moscow, might there still be some de-escalation in their aggressive actions? Or will they simply fail to make further gains on the front lines, will the terror continue, and will these talks actually be about something else entirely?

If the Defense Forces maintain their current rate of inflicting casualties on Russian manpower – even with minimal Russian resupply – and if we continue the same campaign of long-range strikes and Ukraine survives the winter – and I have no doubt it will –

Then, perhaps, a completely different negotiating landscape will emerge by spring, and the question will be whether Putin dares to launch a full-scale mobilization – which, in any case, won’t resolve the issues on a global scale. That’s why it seems to me that Putin long ago missed the moment when he had the best opportunities for negotiations.

He had two such opportunities. Last spring, when Trump was as pro-Putin as he could be, and, presumably, roughly this spring and summer, when the composition of the new U.S. Congress was still unclear.

And it seems to me that these attempts to crush Ukraine over the winter look rather strange now, considering what we’ve already been through, and that most Ukrainians who remain in the country and remain loyal to it will survive this winter. But whether Putin’s army will survive this winter – that’s a big question.

And why wasthe Pentagon’s reaction to Ukraine’s strikes on the Crimean Bridge what it was?

Because Pete Hagseth has hired people who clearly sympathize with the dictator Putin. And the question here is how much longer these people will remain at large. Not even in their positions, but on the loose. Because after January 3, I think Hagseth will be the first to resign – or the first to be forced out by Congress.

Pete Hegset is the man who botched the Iran campaign and, in general, allowed an idiotic, unnecessary war to begin. Pete Hegset blocked aid to Ukraine when it had not been authorized by anyone. He has a string of corruption and political scandals.

So I think the question is how much longer his team will remain in power. It’s clear that they are among the main drivers behind the blocking of aid. It’s clear that they have pro-Russian leanings, but the question is how much longer they’ll be around.

What are the prospects for relations between Ukraine and the United States next year? How would you describe them now? Because the relationship between Ukraine and Europe is clear. But how would you characterize our relationship with the United States right now? Is it a partnership, an alliance, or something much worse?

It seems to me that it has been much worse for a long time now. And it seems to me that the key point here is that we have reasonable relations with many Americans, including representatives of both parties.

At the same time, our relationship with the Trump administration is essentially an attempt not to fall out with them completely – so to speak – in order to maintain some line of communication.

In other words, by and large, our diplomacy has one goal regarding relations with Trump: to minimize the damage caused by his presidency. In other words, we must understand that he is not really a mediator in these negotiations. He openly sides with Russia; he is a sympathizer of Putin and other dictatorships. We are minimizing the damage.

Can this be a partnership? If you and your partner are busy trying to minimize the damage, that’s not a partnership.

But at the same time, we must understand that relations with the White House administration are one thing. It is insane, incompetent, inadequate, and pro-Russian. And then there are relations with the American political establishment, including the Republican Party. These are relations with partners who “are a little under the weather, but they’ll recover.” We believe that. They’ll get rid of this “red plague,” and things will sort themselves out somehow.

Why does Donald Trump actually despise Europe so much? Europe is indeed becoming much more independent than it was just a few years ago. One could even cynically say it’s thanks to Donald Trump. So why does he despise these Europeans so much? Where does this desire come from to hold hands – as if on an escalator – with Xi Jinping in China?

It seems to me that, fundamentally, he fears Europe because it represents an alternative model of a successful West. And no matter how much anyone may criticize Europe, it remains a region with a higher level of social peace – a social reality that is uncomfortable for Trump. That’s why I think this is the main reason.

Plus, they’re very afraid of European competition. And because Americans, like Russians, have an interest in keeping Europe as fragmented as possible. They’re working to divide the European Union, just like the Russians.

You have to understand that even here, Trump would like to be friends with Xi. He’s also a dictator, an emperor. In reality, Xi Jinping is a man who also usurped power in China. Because, yes, China is a one-party system, but there used to be a tradition that no leader could serve for more than ten years. Xi Jinping abolished that rule. In other words, since 2012 – for fourteen years now – the term-limit restriction has been lifted. So this is essentially a role model.

But there are so many conflicts between the U.S. and China that Trump cannot ignore them. And at the same time, the economic ties are far too significant.

So his “love” for Putin and his “friendship” with Xi are things that cannot be realized, because the U.S. has entirely different interests. And it seems to me that it’s simply his emotions that are pushing him toward friendship with these figures – one a bloodthirsty dictator, the other simply a dictator.

However, reality itself prevents them from merging in the ecstasy of love. But I think that a great many people will eventually ask Trump and his political team what this was all about. Because I think that, starting in December, we’ll see all these wonderful people who advocate friendship with dictatorships testifying before Congress.

And this, by the way, was the “Shenzhen spirit,” as it’s already being called. Before that, there was Anchorage; now there’s Shenzhen. That’s how it is.

Their three meetings together lasted a total of two and a half hours. Serious business negotiations – even on commercial issues, which are on a much smaller scale than “dividing the world” – usually take longer. Moreover, each round of negotiations takes more time.

If we’re talking about the Yalta Conference, it lasted more than a week. If we’re talking about any other conference, they last for days and weeks. The Versailles Peace Conference, which ended World War I, began six months after the cessation of hostilities and lasted over a month.

So it seems to me that this meeting was very convenient for Xi. He demonstrated that these two had come to him. One is essentially a “political corpse” – who will remain president for the time being but has effectively lost a great deal of power – and the other is his vassal.

Why did Trump need this? I still don’t understand. Why did Putin need this? It’s clear – to sit down with them at the same table. In other words, Trump orchestrated this meeting. Did he resolve any issues? None.

It would have made sense, you know, under what circumstances? If it had taken place either before the election, or if the congressional elections had ended differently. But as it stands, it looks like a political failure came to meet another political failure – one who couldn’t defeat a country he’s always despised and is unlikely to defeat now.

Let’s be objective: we’ll still have to suffer a lot, but he won’t defeat Ukraine anymore. They came to see a man who isn’t at war with anyone, who is clearly the absolute ruler of his country, and who reigns over all of East Asia. It seems to me that the winner – both symbolic and de facto – is clear here: it’s Xi Jinping. He was toying with them.

By the way, opinions are divided regarding Taiwan’s future. Some say attacks will happen within the next year or two. Others say this will never happen because we don’t understand China well enough, because it’s a delicate matter. What’s your take on this?

I think we don’t know the answer. Forgive me for being, obviously, predictable, because we’ve already been through this “it will never happen” line before. More than once. That’s the first point.

Second. Again, there are currently no reasons why Xi Jinping would attack Taiwan, because in any case, he needs Taiwan as a technological base and a massive economic asset – he doesn’t want to end up with nothing. They will, of course, apply political pressure. For them, Taiwan is a matter of principle.

But if, for example, a serious economic crisis were to break out in China, or there were a political crisis, or tensions with the West were to escalate, or the legitimacy of the regime were called into question – Many dictators have resorted to the tactic of a small, victorious war. And if the situation in China itself dictates that such a war is necessary, it could break out. So, once again, we need to keep an eye on how things unfold.

But we must always remember that countries like China and India – these giants – always prioritize maintaining the stability of the system above all else. In other words, for them, the main priority is to preserve the stability of the state itself, the state system, and the political system – if we’re talking about China. And

that’s why I view all these stories about the division of the world with great irony. China isn’t the one deciding this. China uses its economy, politics, and security issues to maintain the stability of its own existence. And this is a fundamental characteristic of both Chinese civilization and state tradition, as well as Indian ones.

China has had emperors, communists, republicans, and now nationalists, because the CCP is, in fact, already the nationalist party of China.

All these different models of governance have ensured only one thing – the stability of the Chinese system. Because it is too large a country, too vast an empire. Its task, as a continental empire, is to preserve its stability. And I think that’s why the likelihood of a military operation against Taiwan is low.

But if the system is destabilized, then that likelihood increases. Just as Putin invaded Ukraine both times. First, after mass protests following the elections, and then after COVID, the legitimacy of his rule was called into question. Both times, Putin initiated external aggression.

Putin just said that he is very grateful to Trump for the invitation to the summit in Miami in mid-December, but he won’t be coming – he doesn’t want to leave Russia unnecessarily. Does he not want to meet with Volodymyr Zelenskyy? Or is he simply a war criminal who could be imprisoned?

Or is the G20 “ not such a comfortable atmosphere ”? Because the leaders from Southeast Asia and East Asia who were there are quite tolerant; they were more indifferent toward Putin, and it’s obvious that they can’t argue with China.

But when European leaders arrive – and the Australian prime minister is coming – does he really care about Putin, honestly? In other words, he’d face being ignored, obvious humiliation, and a refusal to shake his hand. And that’s incredibly uncomfortable for Putin. He’s a very insecure, sensitive guy.

In 2014, the then-Prime Minister of Australia refused to shake his hand after the occupation of Crimea, and for Putin, that was a real psychological trauma. And there could be plenty of that here. And he’s paranoid, after all. He thinks, “I’m surrounded by enemies; I don’t know who’s controlling the situation; they won’t let me do it, and the Main Intelligence Directorate will be there – some Budanov will sneak up and poison poor Putin.”

When your conscience isn’t clear, you become paranoid. I think Putin is, quite simply, very scared.

It certainly won’t be a warm bath. However, I’ve been following what the Europeans have been saying. They’ve suggested that they might meet with Putin there. I mean, I understand that 99.9% of this would concern Ukraine, but they still anticipated that somewhere along the line, they’d give him a “little hard time.”

Yes, and that’s not very pleasant for him either, because it’s clear that aside from Trump, there won’t be any sympathizers there. That is, among the G20 countries that might sympathize with Putin – not that they’d be neutral – there’s Indonesia, India, China, and Brazil. Turkey to some extent, but there are issues; all the other countries are hostile toward Putin.

Let me remind you that the G7 includes Australia, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Spain. In other words, none of these countries are pro-Russian, to put it mildly.