Онлайн Редакція Вакансії Контакти Ігри Гороскоп
16 November, 17:00
5

Putin Seeks to Dictate the Terms of Peace: What the Kremlin Is Trying to Achieve With Its Absurd Ultimatums

Key points
  • The Kremlin is issuing ultimatums regarding NATO in an attempt to derail negotiations to end the war and extract concessions from the West at Ukraine’s expense.
  • Russia is seeking to reduce the amount of military aid to Ukraine by exploiting internal crises in European democracies to pressure their governments.

Israeli military analyst David Sharp, in an exclusive analytical report for 24 Channel, explained the hidden motives behind Washington’s and Moscow’s recent actions amid talk of negotiations.

Russia is once again dusting off its old ultimatums regarding NATO, attempting to present them as an allegedly integral part of the future architecture of European security. Behind the Kremlin’s loud demands lies a thoroughly pragmatic calculation: Moscow wants not only to derail negotiations to end the war but also to extract concessions from the West that will weaken Ukraine’s position.

In an exclusive analysis for 24 Channel, military analyst David Sharp examined why Putin is returning to the 2021 ultimatums, which weaknesses of European democracies Moscow is banking on, and whether the proposals from Donald Trump’s envoys could truly form the basis of a future peace agreement.

Russian diplomatic moves – in particular, references to the 2021 ultimatum demanding that NATO roll back to its 1997 borders – serve a dual purpose. In 2021, these demands were deliberately detached from reality – they were put forward solely as media and ideological justification for a full-scale invasion that had already been planned.

The Kremlin has driven itself into a situation where the West’s refusal has become a formal pretext for aggression.

Meanwhile, Foreign Minister Andriy Sibiga pointed out the danger Moscow’s new demands regarding NATO. According to the official, those same claims are now resurfacing under the guise of discussions about reforming European security, but have nothing to do with a willingness to achieve genuine peace.

Moscow’s current rhetoric is based on the logic of an “Eastern bazaar.” By putting forward a multitude of completely inflated and unrealistic demands, Russia is pursuing two goals:

  • First, to create an artificial pretext for refusing to engage in substantive peace negotiations regarding Ukraine.
  • The second is to force its opponents to gladly agree to smaller, but entirely mundane concessions, just to reject the most absurd points of the ultimatum.

European countries are not in a position to accept Putin’s dictates, yet the Kremlin takes the demands to restrict arms supplies to Ukraine very seriously.

More on Moscow’s ultimatums: watch the video

Russia’s main strategic goal today is to reduce the volume of military and financial aid to Ukraine from the West. Putin is counting on the vulnerability of democratic systems in the face of prolonged crises. Unlike in autocracies, where decisions are made quickly (albeit often based on flawed intelligence, as was the case in 2022), democratic leaders are bound by electoral cycles.

Politicians in Europe are forced to balance their moral obligation to support Ukraine with the pragmatic interests of their own voters, who are experiencing a decline in their standard of living. The farther a country is from Russia’s borders (such as France or Spain), the less its citizens feel an existential threat.

This creates fertile ground for politicians like Marine Le Pen, who propose cutting aid to Kyiv in order to address domestic economic problems. Russia is actively fueling these sentiments through hybrid attacks, sabotage, and disinformation campaigns, attempting to intimidate Europeans or force them to redirect funds from supporting the Ukrainian Armed Forces to their own defense budgets.

Meanwhile, the visit by representatives of U.S. President Donald Trump – Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner to Moscow – and their behind-the-scenes proposals regarding Ukraine’s accession to NATO in exchange for ceding part of the Donetsk region should not be viewed as Washington’s final plan.

According to the analyst, this is a classic “brainstorming” exercise by the administration, aimed at gauging the positions of the parties involved. American mediators are trying to understand where Kyiv and Moscow are willing to compromise and where their “red lines” lie.

This idea is fundamentally at odds with Russian demands. While Moscow is demanding the virtual dissolution of the Alliance and the withdrawal of new members, the U.S.’s behind-the-scenes proposal calls for NATO’s expansion at Ukraine’s expense.

For the Kremlin, this creates a conceptual trap: Putin has for years justified the war by the need to “defend the Donbas,” and halting at the current front line while redrawing the borders of the Donetsk region could serve as a way for him to sell at least some semblance of a “victory” to his own population rather than admit to a strategic failure.